Nestled along the picturesque shores of Lantana, Florida, The Old Key Lime House boasts a storied legacy as one of the state’s oldest waterfront dining establishments. Established in 1889, this vibrant family-owned restaurant claims the title of “Florida’s oldest waterfront restaurant” and continues to draw both locals and tourists to its inviting premises.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/old-key-lime-house-090926-1-dfd97c6f40e94d7c9f32eec5e3248408.jpg)
With its distinctive neon green exterior, the restaurant overlooks the South Florida Intracoastal Waterway, providing stunning views that complement its extensive dining options. The establishment features both dock access for boaters and patio seating for those wishing to soak up the sun. Notably, The Old Key Lime House is not solely about the breathtaking location; it also prides itself on serving fresh seafood and traditional fare, highlighted by its renowned family key lime pie recipe.
The history of The Old Key Lime House is rich and multifaceted. Initially built as a family home, it transitioned into a dining venue that has served the community for over a century. Historical memorabilia and vintage photographs of past owners with celebrities adorn its walls, contributing to a warm, nostalgic atmosphere. The restaurant has faced and overcome numerous challenges throughout its long history, including the devastating impacts of Hurricane Wilma in 2004, yet it has continually rebuilt and adapted.
The culinary offerings at The Old Key Lime House showcase the best of local cuisine. Guests can savour fresh seafood prepared from locally caught ingredients, with popular options including crab cakes, flavourful soups, and vibrant salads. The bar offers an array of refreshing beverages, from classic rum runners to invigorating mojitos, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy.
A highlight of the menu is undoubtedly the key lime pie, a dish that holds familial significance for owner Ryan Cordero. Cordero’s great-grandmother, Agnes Cordero, is credited with creating the key lime pie recipe back in 1840. The pie, celebrated for its creamy tartness, features a luscious cinnamon graham cracker crust topped with a generous mound of whipped cream, making it a quintessential Florida dessert that patrons return for time and again.
In addition to its culinary delights, The Old Key Lime House embraces the spirit of community with regular live music performances, enhancing its reputation as a lively gathering spot. The restaurant is known for its laid-back atmosphere, where visitors can unwind and enjoy good food, great music, and the company of friends. Cordero characterises it as reminiscent of the beloved TV show “Cheers,” where patrons feel like part of a close-knit community and are welcomed by friendly faces.
Despite its deep-rooted history, The Old Key Lime House remains modern and connected with its audience through an active social media presence. The restaurant frequently shares lively content, including humorous takes on restaurant life and promotions for popular menu items like its famed double smash cheeseburger and Caesar salad. This blend of traditional charm and contemporary engagement has helped cement its place in the hearts of many.
While The Old Key Lime House does not take reservations or offer call-ahead seating, this approach fosters a spontaneous and communal atmosphere. Guests can navigate the lively space and enjoy the exhilarating vibe while sampling the outdoor seating areas, perfect for catching the evening breeze along the waterway.
In summary, The Old Key Lime House stands as a testament to Florida’s rich culinary history and community spirit. Its blend of fresh seafood, people-centric environment, and a legendary key lime pie recipe ensure its continued appeal to diners seeking both flavour and a hint of nostalgia. As the establishment thrives into its 136th year, it remains a cherished destination on the vibrant South Florida waterfront, inviting patrons to experience its unique charm and delicious offerings.