“Two Strangers ”Stars Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty Soar Above N.Y.C. in Breathtaking ‘If I Believed’ Video (Exclusive)

A new music video for the emotional ballad “If I Believed,” taken from the acclaimed Broadway production *Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)*, has recently been unveiled, showcasing a stunning rooftop performance by Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty. The video, which premiered on PEOPLE, offers viewers a glimpse of the actors performing high above Manhattan at Edge, as well as intimate behind-the-scenes glimpses of their offstage camaraderie, which closely mirrors their onstage chemistry.

The gripping duet features prominently near the climax of the musical, which has received nominations for eight Tony Awards, including Best Musical. The song captures a pivotal moment as Pitts and Tutty’s characters, Robin and Dougal, contemplate the serendipitous connection they have formed while exploring the vibrant streets of New York City. The narrative beautifully encapsulates the unexpected relationships that shape us at crucial junctures in our lives.

Interspersed with breathtaking visuals of the Manhattan skyline, the video captures candid moments from Pitts and Tutty’s shared journey since the show’s inception. Footage from behind the curtain includes laughter-filled interactions, light-hearted antics from promotional events, and heartfelt celebrations following the opening night, all of which highlight the genuine friendship that has blossomed between the two stars. Their offstage bond adds an emotional depth that resonates throughout their performances, making them an engaging duo on stage.

The closing title card of the video poignantly states, “Musicals are like people. Sometimes the one you least expect changes you the most.” This sentiment echoes the very essence of *Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)*, which has struck a chord with audiences, leading to its status as a significant hit this season.

*Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)* made its Broadway debut in November 2025, following successful runs in both Boston and London’s West End. Under the direction and choreography of Tony nominee Tim Jackson, the production is currently staged at the Longacre Theatre in New York City. The musical was created by Tony-nominated writing duo Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, who have crafted a heartfelt story centred around Dougal, an optimistic Brit embarking on a life-changing journey, and Robin, the hesitant sister of the bride who reluctantly assists him.

The chemistry between Pitts and Tutty has garnered particular praise from critics and audiences alike. Pitts, who has a strong Broadway pedigree with roles in productions such as *King Kong* and *A Bronx Tale*, remarked on their connection: “It was a lock-in. We are really good friends, and I think people comment on our chemistry a lot. We like to think that it’s because we’re good actors, which is true, but we have built such a real outside friendship.”

Tutty, making his Broadway debut after previously performing in the show in London, shared insights into their evolving relationship on stage. He noted that their genuine friendship sometimes complicates scenes early in the story when their characters have yet to develop familiarity. “I do find myself having to catch myself—stop talking to Robin like you know her,” he commented, reflecting on how their bond influences their performances.

As the buzz around *Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)* continues to grow, tickets for the show are currently available for interested theatre-goers. The musical, with its combination of heartfelt storytelling, remarkable performances, and the picturesque backdrop of New York City, promises to leave a lasting impression on audiences.

In a season marked by an array of musical offerings, Pitts and Tutty’s partnership exemplifies the essence of connection and transformation. “If I Believed” serves not only as a powerful narrative explication within the musical but also as a representation of the journey that the performers have taken together, both on and off stage. The music video stands as a testament to their shared experience, celebrating the magic of theatre and its ability to forge bonds that resonate with audiences.