Celebrity stylist Jessica Paster recently found herself caught up in a controversial incident outside The Carlyle Hotel ahead of the 2025 Met Gala. Paster, known for styling high-profile clients like Olympian Simone Biles and model Miranda Kerr, alleged that she was “manhandled” by the police as she attempted to enter the hotel to prepare for the prestigious event.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/jessica-paster-050725-5654723c92024be8b044129e68c7937a.jpg)
Video footage captured by Reuters shows Paster, dressed in casual attire, being escorted away from the main lobby entrance of the hotel by law enforcement and security personnel. The incident unfolded as Reuters had set up a live feed to capture the arrivals and departures of celebrities staying at the hotel in preparation for the gala.
According to reports, Paster was heard telling the authorities, “I’m staying at this hotel,” as she was embroiled in a scuffle with them. Speaking to Page Six, Paster recounted the ordeal, stating that she was following instructions given to her, only to be unexpectedly treated aggressively by the police. She expressed feeling “manhandled” and in physical pain, even suggesting that her arms could have been broken during the altercation.
In response to the incident, the NYPD issued a statement indicating that a female individual had attempted to access the hotel through the main entrance but was denied entry by hotel security. The statement clarified that after being redirected to the service entrance to obtain proper credentials, the individual was ultimately escorted back to the main entrance by both police and hotel security before being allowed entry.
Despite the unfolding of events, neither Jessica Paster nor The Carlyle Hotel have provided a response to requests for comment. This incident comes in the professional aftermath of Paster receiving criticism for the pink Dior dress she styled Quinta Brunson in for the 2024 Emmys. The dress, which appeared wrinkled in photos, garnered online commentary questioning its appearance and styling execution.
Nevertheless, Paster defended her styling choices for the red carpet look, explaining that the crushed satin material was intentionally designed to create a unique silhouette. Despite facing public scrutiny, Paster stood by her creative decisions and upheld the aesthetic vision she had for her client.
As the story continues to unfold, Jessica Paster’s experience outside The Carlyle Hotel serves as a reminder of the challenges and conflicts that can arise in the fast-paced and high-stakes world of celebrity styling. The incident sheds light on the complexities and pressures faced by industry professionals, even on one of fashion’s most glamorous nights.