A custody hearing held on 8th July in a Utah courtroom drew significant attention as the judge reprimanded Dakota Mortensen for riding a motorcycle with his two-year-old son, Ever. Commissioner Russell Minas made his disapproval clear during the proceedings, stating, “We’re not going to do that anymore,” when Mortensen’s attorney admitted to the motorcycle incident occurring during a custody exchange.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Dakota-Mortensen-court-2026-070826-8a6b8d3e54d74fb98f5b1e4f7c210d74.jpg)
The hearing was focused on the custody arrangements between Mortensen and his ex-girlfriend, Taylor Frankie Paul, who rose to fame through the reality show “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.” Following the judge’s ruling, Paul was granted increased parental time with Ever, extending her custody arrangements through to Monday mornings. This adjustment marked a change from a prior ruling made on 1st June that allocated custody to Paul on alternating weekends and allowed for a midweek visit that did not include overnight stays.
In addition to the custody amendments, the court mandated that Ever is transported exclusively in “enclosed vehicles” equipped with appropriate safety features for his age. The judge also reiterated previous directives prohibiting both parties from making disparaging comments about one another on social media platforms.

After the hearing, a source close to Paul expressed her satisfaction with the judge’s decision, highlighting her eagerness to expand on the progress made during the latest hearing. This development is part of an ongoing and tumultuous custody battle that has attracted considerable media scrutiny since it began earlier this year. The situation has been further complicated by various police investigations stemming from earlier allegations of violent conduct by both Mortensen and Paul.

Reports indicate that the conflicts between the former couple escalated notably in February, leading to several complaints made to local law enforcement regarding alleged violent incidents. A video released in 2023 further showcased a confrontation between Mortensen and Paul, which resulted in ABC pulling the plug on the filming of Paul’s season of “The Bachelorette,” a show that had already finished filming.
Compounding the custody drama, Mortensen sought a protective order against Paul in March, which prompted Paul to file her own counterclaims shortly thereafter. On 30th April, both protective orders were granted for a duration of three years, aligning with the ongoing tensions between the two.
Moreover, Paul’s ex-husband, Tate, filed for a restraining order against her on 30th June, although the court declined his request shortly thereafter. The custody issues come against the backdrop of reports in June revealing that Paul momentarily entered a rehab facility, a situation she later addressed in an Instagram video, reflecting on the necessity for a personal reset.
In recent court submissions, Paul has accused Mortensen of stalking, claiming incidents of violence that included him allegedly slamming her head into his vehicle’s dashboard. Meanwhile, Mortensen has presented photographic evidence of injuries he purportedly sustained during altercations, including visible scratches.
Paul herself faced legal troubles earlier in 2023 arising from a domestic violence incident featuring Mortensen, where she was accused of aggression against him while her daughter was present. Ultimately, she accepted a guilty plea to aggravated assault while other charges were withdrawn.
As the standoff between Mortensen and Paul continues, the future of both the reality television franchise and ongoing productions remains uncertain. Although ABC truncated the release of Paul’s Bachelorette season earlier this spring, reports suggest that there might still be plans to air it in the future. Furthermore, while production on the fifth season of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” has been disrupted, it has been reported that filming for new confessionals is ongoing.
The tumultuous legal battle and personal strife faced by Mortensen and Paul exemplify a troubling intersection of celebrity and custody disputes, drawing attention from both fans and legal observers alike as they await the outcomes of future hearings.
