Kathryn Stockett, the bestselling author renowned for her 2009 novel “The Help,” is grappling with the complexities of criticism as she prepares to release her first book in 16 years, “The Calamity Club.” In a recent discussion with Oprah Winfrey, Stockett reflected on the contentious reception of “The Help” and voiced her ongoing concerns regarding public reaction to her new work.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Kathryn-Stockett-Oprah-Winfrey-060526-db4c27714d7e4c868886b6481479c0ad.jpg)
“The Help,” while a commercial success, faced backlash for its depiction of African American characters primarily through a White lens. Acknowledging this critical viewpoint, Stockett revealed that she briefly contemplated crafting narratives solely based on White experiences in the wake of the novel’s criticism. However, she ultimately decided to continue exploring the nuanced relationships between Black and White communities, particularly those prevalent in her home state of Mississippi.
As Stockett embarks on the release of “The Calamity Club,” she admits to lingering apprehensions about how her storytelling will be received. “I’m still worried,” she expressed during her conversation with Winfrey. This concern is rooted in the backlash her previous work encountered, mirroring her worries about repeating similar missteps. “I am a White woman, and it’s… a story about White people and Black people, and the relationships that they have,” she added.
Moreover, Stockett acknowledged the criticisms that her first novel primarily presented events from a White perspective, a sentiment echoed by Viola Davis—who starred as Aibileen Clark in the film adaptation of “The Help.” Davis has since publicly regretted the emphasis on White narratives, arguing that the true voices of the Black maids were not adequately represented. In a 2018 interview with The New York Times, she articulated her desire for a more authentic portrayal of the Black experience within the context of domestic work during the 1960s.
Despite her critiques of the film, Davis expressed gratitude for the connections she forged during the production. She highlighted the friendships and collaborative relationships as a silver lining amid her reservations about the film’s narrative focus.
Bryce Dallas Howard, who portrayed Hilly Holbrook, shared similar sentiments about the importance of authenticity and representation in storytelling. In light of the ongoing discourse on racial inequality and following the global Black Lives Matter protests in 2020, Howard candidly noted that she would opt against participating in a project like “The Help” today, underlining the need for stories told from the perspectives of Black creators.
With the release of “The Calamity Club,” Stockett is shifting her focus to a new narrative, set during the Great Depression. The novel intertwines the lives of three women in Mississippi: Meg, an orphan; Birdie, a woman seeking aid from her estranged sister; and Charlie, a woman attempting to escape her tumultuous past. The story is expected to explore themes of sisterhood and resilience amidst adversity, with Stockett hinting that her trademark balance of humour and serious subject matter remains integral to her writing approach.
Stockett has indicated that “The Calamity Club” aims to spark conversations about women’s rights and autonomy in a contemporary context. She expressed a determination to address challenging themes while injecting levity into her narrative, which she believes is fundamental to her storytelling style.
While Stockett may brace for scrutiny as she unveils her latest novel, she remains steadfast in her belief that literature can serve as a vehicle for illuminating complex social dynamics. The author acknowledged that, despite potential backlash, her intention is to celebrate women’s agency in shaping their destinies. “Above all, the story embraces a woman’s right to determine her own fate, which feels increasingly relevant these days,” she remarked.
As “The Calamity Club” makes its way to readers, Stockett’s reflections on her past, combined with her aspirations for the future, reveal both a commitment to evolving as a storyteller and a desire to engage in meaningful dialogues around race, gender, and identity. While the shadow of “The Help” looms large, Stockett is poised to turn the page and navigate the terrain of her new narrative, in hopes of sparking both reflection and discussion in her audience.