Carrie Preston Says She Thought Her Husband Michael Emerson Was Gay When They Met

Carrie Preston Reveals Surprising First Impression of Husband Michael Emerson

In a recent podcast appearance, actress Carrie Preston disclosed a misconception she held about her husband, Michael Emerson, whom she believed was gay when they first crossed paths almost three decades ago. The couple initially met during a production of Hamlet at the Alabama Shakespeare Festival in the 1990s.

Preston, known for her role as Elsbeth, shared the amusing anecdote on Jesse Tyler Ferguson’s “Dinner’s On Me” podcast on October 7th. She reminisced about her first impression of Emerson, now 71, recalling how she thought he was gay due to his impeccable style, donning a three-piece suit during rehearsals. Preston humorously remarked, “He’s gay. Oh, no, OK, I have another crush on the gay guys.”

The actress, aged 58, further explained that her brother, fellow actor John G. Preston, who was also part of the Hamlet production, reassured her about Emerson’s orientation, encouraging her to pursue a romantic relationship with him. Preston jokingly recalled her initial hesitation, thinking, “But he’s gay, right?” It was her brother’s adamant response that finally convinced her otherwise.

Despite her initial misconception, Emerson reciprocated Preston’s romantic interest by presenting her with flowers and inviting her to a party. This marked the beginning of their journey towards marriage, which culminated in their wedding in 1998. The couple recently celebrated an impressive 27 years of matrimony.

Reflecting on their enduring relationship in an interview with PEOPLE, Preston highlighted the challenges of balancing their careers as television stars while keeping their bond strong and fresh. She mentioned the importance of cherishing the time they spend together, considering their frequent periods of separation due to work commitments.

Emphasizing the positive impact of distance on their relationship, Preston noted that being apart often leads to a heightened appreciation for each other’s company. She firmly believes in the adage, “Absence makes the heart grow fonder,” underscoring the significance of valuing the time they have together and not taking it for granted.

Regarding their professional collaboration, Preston expressed her desire to work alongside Emerson, ideally having him guest star on her show. She mused about potential roles for him and eagerly anticipated the possibility of having him join her in the unique world of Elsbeth.

As fans eagerly await the on-screen reunion of this talented couple, Preston’s endearing anecdotes about their relationship continue to captivate audiences, showcasing a love story that defied initial misconceptions and blossomed into a lasting partnership filled with mutual admiration and respect.