An American Pope: The Potential Contenders
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/pope-francis-memorial-042425-e83305101d4d40fda8672ddd07a9b653.jpg)
By Charlotte Phillipp | Updated on April 25, 2025
Following the passing of Pope Francis, speculation abounds regarding his successor. However, experts caution that the upcoming conclave presents a challenge due to the diverse group of cardinals involved. Dr. Bill Cavanaugh, a Catholic studies professor at DePaul University, notes that the cardinals, many appointed by Francis, lack familiarity with each other, making it tricky to predict the outcome.
While various names are circulating as possible contenders for the papacy, history has shown that the leading figures are not always chosen. For instance, Pope Francis was not initially a frontrunner in 2013. Despite this unpredictability, some cardinals are being earmarked as potential pontiffs based on their characteristics and stances.
The question on whether an American could ascend to the papacy has intrigued many. Dr. Cavanaugh believes it to be unlikely due to America’s existing global influence. However, he mentions Cardinal Joseph Tobin of Newark as a candidate with attributes similar to Pope Francis but deems his selection improbable.
Another suggested American contender is Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago, recognised for his stance against mass deportations in the US. While not viewed as theologically perfect, some believe he aligns with Pope Francis’ principles. The likelihood of other American candidates, like Timothy Dolan of New York, seems slim due to various factors such as age, politics, or health.
One significant aspect to consider is that Pope Francis appointed a substantial number of the voting cardinals, shaping their ideologies and perspectives. The upcoming conclave comprises diverse cardinals from around the globe, presenting differing views and making the selection process even more intricate according to experts.
Anthea Butler, a religious studies professor at the University of Pennsylvania, speculates that an Asian or African pope might emerge, marking a historic moment. While names like Cardinal Robert Sarah and Cardinal Peter Turkson have been mentioned, experts view Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle from the Philippines as a potential moderate choice representing a growing Catholic presence.
Experts emphasise the inherent uncertainty surrounding the next papal selection. Dr. Cavanaugh emphasises the equal plausibility of the numerous potential candidates, leaving the outcome wide open. Despite speculations and predictions, the final decision remains shrouded in mystery until the conclave convenes and the next pope is chosen.
As the world waits with bated breath for the announcement of the 267th pope, the spotlight remains on the College of Cardinals as they deliberate on selecting the next pontiff from a pool of diverse and globally representative candidates. The anticipation builds as the papal conclave approaches, offering a glimpse into the future direction of the Catholic Church.