In a perplexing case that has attracted considerable media attention, a Florida couple, Tiffany Score and Steven Mills, are grappling with the aftermath of a distressing in vitro fertilisation (IVF) mix-up involving their daughter, Shea. The couple has recently reached a custody agreement with Shea’s biological parents, marking a significant development in a story that has been unfolding since their daughter’s birth in December 2025.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Tiffany-Score-and-Steven-Mills-190-06232026-df9594a683e04f7ba2682301165e126d.jpg)
Initially, Score and Mills were overjoyed when they welcomed Shea, believing her to be the product of their own IVF efforts. However, they soon faced a shocking realisation: their daughter was not genetically related to them. The couple’s attempts to locate the true biological parents of their child have been met with both relief and gratitude, as expressed by Score’s sister, Alexa, in a statement released through a GoFundMe page set up to support the family.
On June 22, in an update shared on the fundraising platform, Alexa detailed how the family had successfully identified Shea’s biological parents and crafted a mutually agreed upon custody arrangement. She commented on the selflessness exhibited by all parties involved, expressing pride in the collaborative spirit that had emerged during such a challenging time. “Our family’s hearts are filled with relief and gratitude,” she remarked.
Despite this progress in their personal lives, Score and Mills remain determined to get to the bottom of how the mix-up occurred at the fertility clinic. Their investigation involves a complex series of legal and medical procedures, including genetic testing and the transport of their last viable embryo. Alexa explained that the process is not only intricate but also financially burdensome, with no assured results.
“The support from the community has been invaluable, allowing them to remain focused on what truly matters: nurturing their daughter Shea,” Alexa continued. “Every act of kindness has helped them navigate one of the most challenging chapters of their lives.” She assured followers that more updates would follow “when the time is right,” signalling their desire for privacy as they adjust to their new family dynamics.
The custody agreement allows Score and Mills to retain their status as permanent custodial parents of Shea, while the identities of the biological parents remain confidential, as detailed in court documents obtained by media sources. The couple has expressed a commitment to fostering a relationship with Shea’s genetic parents, seeking to navigate this unprecedented situation positively.
The flip side of this story shines a light on the biological parents, who are now pursuing accountability from the clinic involved in the IVF mishap. Their attorney, Rob Marcereau, disclosed plans to file a civil suit against the Fertility Center of Orlando in the near future, emphasising their need for answers regarding the incident. This legal pursuit emerges after Score and Mills had previously filed their own lawsuit against the clinic.
The Fertility Center of Orlando has since shuttered its operations and redirected clients to a different facility, which has retained some of its staff. Neither the clinic nor Dr. Milton McNichol, who is associated with the case, has publicly responded to requests for comment about the situation.
As this family continues to piece together their lives amid uncertainty, the broader implications of this case raise significant questions about the IVF process and the safeguards needed to prevent such occurrences in the future. With their daughter now firmly in their lives, Score and Mills hope to protect her while seeking clarity on the events that led them to this moment.
The community remains supportive as the couple embarks on this unpredictable journey, highlighting the resilience of familial love in the face of adversity. Tiffany Score and Steven Mills are not only battling to comprehend the complexities of their IVF experience, but they’re also committed to ensuring that their daughter grows up surrounded by love and understanding—no matter where that may lead them.