A former police officer in Kentucky has been indicted on charges of manslaughter and reckless homicide following the fatal shooting of an unarmed and naked man earlier this year. Nathan Stotts, who served with the Louisville Metro Police Department, faces serious accusations in connection with the death of 27-year-old Martin Nitzken Jr. on 30 May.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/nathan-stotts-scene-061626-223ed9ea7f004337a7578db4621e4fe3.jpg)
The indictment, issued by a Jefferson County grand jury, includes one count of second-degree manslaughter and one count of reckless homicide. Although the grand jury concluded that there was insufficient evidence to bring a murder charge against Stotts, the decision to indict him on lesser charges follows a comprehensive review of the circumstances surrounding Nitzken’s death.
The incident took place after police received reports of an alleged assault on the south side of Louisville. Authorities stated that Nitzken had assaulted three women before leaving the scene in a state of undress. Body-camera footage reviewed by police showcases the moments leading up to the shooting, where Stotts is seen confronting Nitzken while brandishing his service weapon. Despite Nitzken being naked and unarmed, Stotts ordered him to stop as Nitzken approached him. The situation culminated in Stotts firing a single shot, which resulted in Nitzken’s demise on the scene.
In the aftermath of the incident, Chief Paul Humphrey of the Louisville Metro Police determined that the use of deadly force in this scenario was unjustifiable. During a press conference held shortly after the incident, he made a pointed statement regarding the actions taken by Stotts, emphasising that the decision to take someone’s life should not be taken lightly. Humphrey expressed his preference for non-lethal methods to have been employed, particularly given Nitzken’s vulnerable state at the time of the encounter.
Before the termination process could conclude, Stotts resigned from the police force, having joined the department in 2024. This resignation came after the police chief had already initiated proceedings to dismiss him based on preliminary reviews of evidence, including body-camera recordings and 911 calls.
Following the announcement of Stotts’s indictment, the Louisville Metro Police Department released a statement affirming their respect for the grand jury’s decision while highlighting their commitment to the judicial process. Meanwhile, Steven Romines, an attorney for Nitzken’s family, expressed his welcome of the charges against Stotts but argued that they did not go far enough, stating that the evidence warranted a murder charge.
Romines remarked on the broader implications of police accountability in cases of excessive use of force, pointing out that law enforcement officers rarely face prosecution following such incidents. He described the footage as illustrating “extreme indifference to human life,” lending weight to his argument that Stotts should face more severe charges.
Under Kentucky law, the possible sentence for second-degree manslaughter ranges from five to ten years, whereas reckless homicide may result in one to five years in prison. Stotts is set to appear in Jefferson County Circuit Court for his arraignment on 22 June, although it is currently unclear whether he has secured legal representation.
The case has sparked conversation regarding the use of lethal force by police officers and the accountability mechanisms in place for such actions, with stakeholders calling for a closer examination of police conduct and training practices. As the legal proceedings unfold, the incident continues to raise questions about the balance between officer safety and the rights of individuals, particularly in vulnerable situations.