**Transformation of Actor Paul Anthony Kelly in ‘Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette’**
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/paul-anthony-kelly-tattoos-2-052126-4b2e2591616345c4a6ec159b20a63356.jpg)
Paul Anthony Kelly, the 37-year-old actor known for his compelling performance in the series ‘Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette,’ underwent a significant transformation to convincingly portray the late political figure. The production team and Kelly himself faced the time-consuming task of concealing his numerous tattoos to accurately represent John F. Kennedy Jr., a challenge that was vividly highlighted in a recent social media post by the show’s makeup lead, Milagros Medina Cerdeira.
In a behind-the-scenes clip, shared on Instagram, Medina Cerdeira showcased the meticulous effort involved in creating Kelly’s on-screen appearance. The video provided a rare insight into how the actor’s real-life body art was effectively obscured, allowing him to meld into the role of JFK Jr. seamlessly. The striking resemblance that Kelly shares with Kennedy not only aided his casting but also drew attention to the detailed processes required to complete his transformation.
Kelly’s tattoos, which he has previously discussed, include over 30 pieces of personal significance, some of which he has expressed regret over. The concealing of these tattoos was no small feat; the process required a dedicated team to apply layers of red ink followed by foundation that matched Kelly’s skin tone. This extensive coverage was necessary, particularly as the character of JFK Jr. was known to have a few tattoos himself, such as a shamrock above his shoulder blade, as mentioned in Liz McNeil and RoseMarie Terenzio’s book, ‘JFK Jr.: An Intimate Oral Biography.’
The actor has shared that getting ready for his role was a lengthy process. In interviews, he noted that he would often spend an hour and a half in the makeup chair, the majority of that time dedicated to tattoo cover-ups. “Honestly, it’s tattoo cover-up,” he explained in a December 2025 interview. “I have quite a few tattoos,” he added, raising awareness of how intricate and commitment-intensive the transition to portraying JFK Jr. could be.
For Kelly, the physical transformation was more than just skin deep. He admitted that he contemplated the narrative behind his tattoos and recognised how they reflected his personal journey through difficult phases of life. “I don’t think I was ever that person, just finding myself in dark days, going through relationship woes and travelling all the time,” he confessed, contemplating the impulsive ink choices made in his youth.
The actor’s hair also required careful styling to match the iconic look of JFK Jr., with a full blowout and careful adjustments to achieve the right aesthetic. “My hairline is not as thick and prominent as John-John’s,” he noted, acknowledging the challenges of matching the late Kennedy’s distinct appearance.
Despite the considerable effort involved in his transformation, Kelly rose to the occasion as a television heartthrob, with ‘Love Story’ garnering significant attention since its release. The show has allowed audiences to connect with the character on a deeper level, moving beyond just a portrayal of the Kennedy legacy to explore the complexities of his personal life.
Moreover, Kelly’s journey resonates beyond the screen. In a profile published in GQ, he candidly discussed his tattoos and their meanings, mentioning a particularly notable “138” tattoo that pays homage to a song by the band Misfits. His reflections on self-expression through body art highlight the interplay between appearance and personal narrative, provoking thought on how physical transformations can mirror emotional journeys.
As the series continues to unfold, viewers are not only captivated by Kelly’s nuanced performance but also by the efforts behind the scenes that make such portrayals possible. ‘Love Story’ serves as a testament to the art of transformation in acting, reminding us that every role is shaped by countless behind-the-scenes decisions and hard work.