Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen Displayed ‘Violence Both Ways,’ Says Judge in Custody Hearing for Son Ever, 2

In a significant legal development, Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen were granted mutual protective orders during a custody hearing held on April 30. The ruling centres around their shared responsibility for their two-year-old son, Ever, and follows ongoing domestic violence investigations involving both parties.

Commissioner Russell Minas presided over the hearing, which was streamed online, marking the first public appearance of the former couple since multiple allegations of domestic violence came to light earlier this year. The Commissioner expressed grave concerns about their ability to co-parent effectively, stating that interactions between the two often lead to volatile situations. “You can’t be in the same place at the same time for very long before it turns violent,” Minas remarked, noting that he found evidence of mutual violence between them.

Minas urged both parents to prioritise their child’s wellbeing above their conflict, stating, “I’m hoping you’re not just people who thrive on the drama and the conflict.” He emphasised the importance of healthy co-parenting, saying that their relationship would forever impact Ever’s development. “You’re modelling how to deal with conflict for a two-year-old,” he warned, emphasising the long-term consequences their current behaviour could have on their child.

In response to the escalating tensions, the Commissioner announced that he intends to enforce distance between Paul and Mortensen. “This is what’s best for Ever,” he declared, noting that all evidence suggested that their interactions were harmful. He remarked that maintaining separation was essential for their son’s safety and wellbeing.

The legal battle between Paul and Mortensen has been intensified by allegations from both sides, prompting investigations by both the Draper City Police and the West Jordan Police. These probes stemmed from conflicting reports of violent altercations that took place in February. However, the Salt Lake County District Attorney’s Office and Draper City Prosecutor later declined to file charges against Paul, citing a lack of sufficient evidence.

In the context of these investigations, Mortensen sought a protective order against Paul, which was subsequently followed by Paul filing a counter-request. Prior to the April 30 hearing, the court had awarded temporary custody of Ever to Mortensen on April 7, allowing Paul limited visitation under supervision. This custody arrangement was viewed as a necessary step while the investigations continued and the court assessed the dynamics between the parents.

Paul’s history of alleged violence is well-documented, including a previous arrest in 2023 for an incident where she was accused of throwing objects during a dispute with Mortensen, all while her then-five-year-old daughter was present. Although Paul pleaded guilty to aggravated assault, many of the other charges were dismissed. Recent media coverage reignited attention surrounding this case, particularly after a video surfaced supporting the allegations of violent behaviour.

Following the release of this footage, the broadcaster ABC took the extraordinary step of cancelling a season of “The Bachelorette” that was set to feature Paul, a decision made mere days before its premiere. This move comes as the network continues to assess the implications of the situation, with executives stating they are taking matters one day at a time.

The fallout from these legal and personal troubles has also affected Paul’s professional life. Reports indicate that production on the fifth season of “Mormon Wives” was momentarily halted as some cast members refused to work with her. Despite the resumption of filming, Paul has chosen to step back from the new season, highlighting the profound impact of her ongoing legal issues.

As the case progresses, both parties are set to receive recommendations regarding their parenting time ahead of another scheduled hearing on June 1. The proceedings have raised serious questions about the future of their co-parenting relationship and the environment in which Ever will grow up.

For those experiencing domestic violence, support is available through the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, providing confidential assistance 24/7 in over 170 languages.