On 20th August 1972, two women in Ohio made a fateful discovery that would change their lives forever. Rita Marshall and her friend Darlene Gilleland found a newborn girl abandoned in a brown paper bag inside a shopping cart at the Westgate Shopping Center in Fairview Park. This summer, after more than five decades, the trio reunited to share their lives and reflections on that momentous event.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/women-found-baby-117-03122026-047eb94dbbfc45c1b3d907e2e92b9542.jpg)
At the time of the incident, Rita, then 20 years old, and Darlene, 23, had just finished watching a film and were heading to Darlene’s car when they noticed the cart near the vehicle’s front bumper. Initially fearing it contained an animal due to the rustling noises, the women were taken aback when they discovered a baby girl nestled within the bag. “She didn’t cry. She didn’t do anything,” recalled Darlene, now 76. “Pearl was so calm and sweet, like an angel.”
The baby, who would later be named Jeanne Westgate by the authorities, was reported as being just moments old, well-dressed, and appeared to be in good health. The women quickly called the police, who were initially suspicious and questioned them about whether either of them was the baby’s mother. Nevertheless, they remained by the infant’s side until paramedics took her to Fairview General Hospital.
“Rita and I were filled with a mixture of concern and protectiveness,” Darlene said. “We knew she needed care, and we were determined to see to it she would get it.” They left the hospital unaware that the child would spend the next few months in the foster care system.
Three months later, the baby girl was adopted by a loving family, including her adoptive mother, who suspected her daughter was the very infant found in the shopping centre. However, this connection could not be confirmed at the time due to the nature of closed adoptions, leaving both the baby’s adoptive family and the women who discovered her with unanswered questions for decades.
Pearl Marshall, born on the day of her abandonment, grew up knowing she was adopted but learned about her potential origins only when her mother finally revealed her suspicions during Pearl’s college years. “I didn’t think there would be a place to start,” Pearl reflected shortly after discovering her birth certificate, which confirmed not just her date of birth but also the location of her discovery.
Encouraged, Pearl and her husband began an online search. They stumbled upon a brief article titled “Abandoned baby found at plaza,” which discussed the incident that had captivated their hometown over fifty years ago. Inspired by the new information, Pearl became determined to learn more about her past.
In June 2023, she reached out to the local police department in hopes of obtaining a report from the incident. Although the station could not provide her with the desired documents, her email was forwarded to Chris Gerrett, a local historian. Chris was intrigued and took it upon herself to assist Pearl in uncovering the facts surrounding her origins.
As Chris dug through public records and contacted potential leads, she discovered Rita and Darlene’s identities. After a few attempts, she successfully reached Darlene’s son, who was astounded to learn of his mother’s involvement in finding the abandoned child. Within days, Chris connected with both women, and they agreed to a reunion that would be over fifty years in the making.
Finally, in the summer of 2023, Rita, Darlene, and Pearl met in person. It was a powerful and emotional gathering, with Rita stating, “I believe that what happened that night was a part of God’s plan for Pearl’s life. Everyone was put in place for her to begin her life’s journey.”
During the reunion, Pearl shared her own story, including her efforts to reconnect with her biological father. Initially shocked to learn of her existence, he embraced Pearl, forging a bond that brought joy to both.
As they reflected on the past, it was clear that although the circumstances of Pearl’s discovery were unfortunate, the enduring kindness of two strangers had a profound impact on her life trajectory. Both Darlene and Rita had consistently thought of Pearl over the years, often wondering how she had turned out. Now, at last, they have the opportunity to celebrate the life and successes of the child they once saved.
With questions finally answered and connections made, this remarkable tale serves as an inspiring reminder of resilience and hope, proving that the bonds of humanity often extend beyond one’s immediate family.