Susan Smith, convicted in 1995 for the harrowing murder of her two young sons, addressed a South Carolina parole board on Thursday, 19 November, expressing deep remorse ahead of her second appeal for release. Smith, who is 55 and serving a life sentence, has been in prison since she drowned her children, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, by letting her car roll into John D. Long Lake.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/susan-smith-parole-hearing-111926-3cf6f43b993b4740a05adca70316fd07.jpg)

In a heartfelt statement, Smith acknowledged the profound pain her actions had inflicted on those who loved her sons. “I want to say that I’m very, very sorry. I want to say I’m sorry to Michael and Alex. They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die,” she expressed emotionally in front of the parole board, moments before her application was unanimously denied.

During the hearing, she specifically addressed her ex-husband, David Smith, highlighting the impact her actions had on his life. “I dropped to my lowest when I let that car go into that lake,” she said. “I want to say to David, and all the people that loved Michael and Alex, that I’m sorry. I know I caused them an unbearable pain. I know that David didn’t get to see Michael and Alex grow up. He didn’t get to see them ride a bike, go to school, and I’m really, really sorry for that.”
David Smith, who vehemently opposed her release, characterised the possibility of her parole as an “injustice” to their children. Testifying at the hearing, he underscored the deliberate nature of Smith’s actions, stating, “It wasn’t an accident. It wasn’t a bad state. She did it deliberately.” He pleaded for the board to consider his enduring grief, describing the pain of a father who witnessed the loss of his sons in such a tragic manner.
David was accompanied by his wife, Tiffany Smith, and their daughter Savannah, along with other family members, all advocating for Susan Smith to remain incarcerated for life. He communicated a lack of interest in hearing about her remorse, suggesting that he believed her claims were insincere. “At this point, I could care less what Susan has to say. I don’t want to talk to her. I don’t want to ask her,” he stated, conveying a sentiment of deep unresolved hurt.
Smith’s parole hearing was her second since becoming eligible last year after serving 30 years of her life sentence. Under South Carolina law, she must wait another two years before she can apply for parole again. Her apology, while heartfelt, has faced significant scrutiny, particularly given the nature of her crime and the manner in which she initially evaded responsibility—a fact which has left a lasting impact on David Smith.
In 1994, following the drowning of her children, Susan Smith initially fabricated a story about a carjacking in which she claimed a Black man had taken her vehicle with the boys still inside, leading to a nationwide search. It was only after nine days that she admitted her role in their deaths, a revelation that shocked the public and garnered extensive media coverage.
Throughout her trial, Smith’s defence team attempted to assert that she was suffering from severe postpartum depression and other mental health disorders that affected her judgment. However, she refuted claims suggesting that her actions were motivated by an affair; “This did not happen because of a man, that’s just not true,” she declared during her parole hearing, denying any external influence on her actions that fateful day.
As the board’s decision was rendered, it became clear that Susan Smith’s journey towards seeking redemption and healing, both for herself and for the families of her victims, remains fraught with complexity and deep emotional scars. The board’s refusal to grant her parole reflects the continued anguish felt by David Smith and the broader community who mourn the loss of two innocent lives.
