David Slater is on a poignant mission to see Canada’s medical aid in dying (MAID) laws expand to include individuals suffering from mental health issues, after enduring the heartbreaking loss of his wife, Diane McDowell. Slater’s advocacy is driven by his intimate experience with the devastating effects of chronic depression and the challenges of navigating a healthcare system that currently does not accommodate mental illness under its assisted dying regulations.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/David-Slater-medical-aid-2-111226-27d7bf0bf75b4f6dbd5e25be8dbed580.jpg)

Slater and McDowell shared 36 years of marriage, and her battle with depression lasted for decades. Despite engaging in various treatments, including medication and therapy, Diane managed to maintain some semblance of normalcy in her life, particularly during their globe-trotting retirement. However, after she decided to taper off her medication in 2012, her mental health took a dramatic turn.

On a trip to Grenada, McDowell expressed discomfort, suggesting they return home. Slater describes this moment as the start of an arduous journey into a darker chapter of her mental health struggles. Once back in Canada, she resumed her medication, but unfortunately, it proved ineffective, leading to a cascade of failed treatments, including transcranial magnetic stimulation, electroconvulsive therapy, and ketamine.
“It came on like a ton of bricks,” Slater remarked, reflecting on the speed with which McDowell’s condition deteriorated. He noted how she had previously managed to keep her illness in remission, but old wounds resurfaced, pushing her past that point. The symptoms intensified, and she experienced debilitating anxiety attacks that often left her incapacitated for hours. Eventually, she was admitted to a psychiatric ward, where she spent extended periods receiving treatment.
Slater noted the considerable toll this took on Diane’s quality of life. “It took me a long time to understand,” he said. He grappled with the common misconception that people suffering from mental illness could simply “snap out of it.” He was acutely aware of her suffering, and he began to fully comprehend the gravity of her condition.
During her ongoing struggle, the couple discussed the concept of MAID. Slater recalls that McDowell frequently expressed interest in the option, a conversation he was willing to support fully. Unfortunately, Canada’s MAID legislation does not currently extend to those suffering solely from mental illnesses. Since its implementation in June 2016, the law has permitted patients with terminal illnesses to seek assisted dying, but plans to include mental health conditions by March 2027 were recently halted by the government amid concerns from the medical community.
Amidst her despair, McDowell contemplated travelling to Switzerland, where assisted dying is permissible for internationals. However, she ultimately decided against the move due to fears that her doctors would hospitalise her for pursuing end-of-life options.
Tragically, Diane McDowell took her own life on 25 October. Just weeks before her death, she articulated a profound sentiment to Slater: “I don’t want to die, but I don’t want to live like this.” This statement epitomises the struggles faced by many who experience debilitating mental health challenges. Slater, overwhelmed with emotion, expressed that this sentiment captures the essence of what MAID represents.
Now a vocal proponent for an expansion of MAID to encompass mental illness, Slater believes such legislation could offer dignity to those enduring similar suffering. He envisions a compassionate end-of-life experience for patients like his wife, surrounded by loved ones reminiscing about cherished memories rather than enduring the agony that often accompanies mental illness.
Slater reminisces about the conversations he and McDowell had about how her final moments could be, envisioning an intimate farewell in a setting filled with warmth and love. The absence of that opportunity haunts him, as he reflects on how he could have held her hand, offering comfort in her last moments.
As Slater advocates for change, he hopes to prevent future grieving spouses from facing the anguish he has endured. His call to action is not only for legislative reform but also for broader societal recognition of mental illness as a legitimate and often fatal condition deserving of compassionate consideration in end-of-life decisions.
If you or anyone you know is grappling with mental health issues or emotional distress, support is available. Reach out to professionals or helplines such as 988, which provides confidential assistance day or night.
