Tom Selleck, famed for his portrayal of Frank Reagan in the long-running procedural drama ‘Blue Bloods,’ has left the door open for a potential return to the franchise, although it hinges on a compelling storyline. Selleck, who graced screens as the NYPD commissioner from the show’s inception in 2010 until its conclusion in 2024, has yet to reprise his role in the new spinoff series ‘Boston Blue,’ which is set to kick off its second season on October 9, 2025.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Tom-Selleck-Blue-Bloods-100724-1-117555692aaf433d84c1c5253aec2892.jpg)
The showrunners of ‘Boston Blue,’ Brandon Margolis and Brandon Sonnier, recently discussed the prospects of Selleck’s return during an interview with Screen Rant. Margolis revealed that they would be keen to have the 81-year-old actor back, but emphasized that the storyline would need to be fitting. “We would love to have Tom and writing for him would be a dream come true,” Margolis stated. However, he noted that any return would need to align with the narrative of the series and complement Frank Reagan’s character.
Margolis described the discussion of Selleck’s potential involvement as a “long, never-ending conversation,” underscoring the actor’s busy schedule and the importance of crafting a story that warrants his return. “It’s always going to come down to what’s the right story to tell, and does it make sense to have Frank there,” he added.
Sonnier echoed this sentiment, reiterating that they were committed to finding the “right story” rather than simply bringing back Selleck for the sake of nostalgia. “The right story that brings Frank into the world of ‘Boston Blue’ will present itself,” he stated, expressing optimism about the possibilities that could arise in future episodes. Both showrunners are keen to ensure that any storyline involving Frank would be not just compelling but memorable.
At the heart of ‘Boston Blue’ is Frank’s son, Danny Reagan, played by Donnie Wahlberg, who has embarked on his own journey following a relocation from New York to Boston with a new partner, Detective Lena Silver, portrayed by Sonequa Martin-Green. While the narrative pivots around Danny, several familiar faces from ‘Blue Bloods’ have made guest appearances, including Len Cariou, Marisa Ramirez, and Bridget Moynahan. Moreover, Will Estes is set to reprise his role as Danny’s brother, Jamie Reagan, in the show’s second season.
The desire for Selleck’s return is not limited to the showrunners; other cast members have expressed similar wishes. Martin-Green shared her enthusiasm in an interview with Woman’s World, stating, “I’d love to have him [Selleck] back,” while also highlighting the importance of ensuring the story is crafted correctly. “We will make sure the story is just right because Tom is so adamant about the story, as he should be,” she remarked, indicating that the collaborative nature of storytelling is vital for all involved.
Selleck himself has previously conveyed some frustration concerning the end of ‘Blue Bloods,’ stating that while he is proud of the show’s legacy, he views ‘Boston Blue’ as a different venture altogether. In an interview with Hour Detroit, he reflected on the importance of ‘Blue Bloods’ in television history but hesitated to commit to an ongoing portrayal of Frank Reagan. “It’s not my lot in life to keep playing Frank Reagan,” he remarked, adding that he could not predict future developments.
As anticipation builds for the second season of ‘Boston Blue,’ scheduled to air on CBS, fans are keen to see how the series evolves. The first season is currently available for streaming on Paramount+. With its returning characters and potential for crossover narratives, the spinoff seeks to carve its own identity while remaining rooted in the beloved legacy of ‘Blue Bloods.’
As dedicated viewers await the return of both familiar faces and potentially new storylines, the question of Tom Selleck’s involvement remains a tantalising possibility that fans continue to hope for. Whether or not the stars align to bring Frank Reagan back to Boston, the commitment of the cast and crew to honour the legacy of ‘Blue Bloods’ is clear, fueling the ongoing conversation about the future of the franchise.