The anticipation for the new season of “Dancing with the Stars” is building as it prepares to return for its 35th iteration on September 15. This year, fans will witness the dynamic reunion of reigning champion Witney Carson with her new celebrity partner, Guillermo Rodriguez. Other intriguing pairings include Bravo’s Ciara Miller dancing with Brandon Armstrong and Love Island’s Maura Higgins teaming up with seasoned professional Mark Ballas.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/guillermo-rodriguez-witney-carson-connor-wood-rylee-arnold-90926-1-860e9431b98244f5b0f6c85774ec1ce5.jpg)
Deena Katz, the show’s executive producer and casting director, plays a vital role in these exciting partnerships. Known for her ability to craft memorable combinations, Katz commented on the approach the team takes when selecting celebrity and pro pairings. Although contestants do have the opportunity to voice their preferences, Katz emphasised that the final decisions rest with her and her team, who view the process as a critical aspect of the show’s appeal.
During the “Behind the Mirrorball” panel at DWTS Con in August 2026, Katz shed light on the factors influencing the pairing decisions. She highlighted the aim of providing variety for both fans and contestants, stating, “You don’t want the same pro to always have a top player… It makes it exciting and better for them.” The selection process considers diverse elements, including compatibility and the dynamic each couple brings to the stage.
Michaela Higgins, who starred on “The Traitors”, has been particularly keen on partnering with Ballas. She openly campaigned for this collaboration, expressing a belief that he would be adept at managing her spirited personality. “I feel like [Mark] would be able to handle me,” she stated, reinforcing her enthusiasm for the partnership.
Notably, Katz also mentioned that while some celebrities may express their preferences for specific professional dancers, these requests cannot always be guaranteed. “We always say we can’t guarantee it. That’s why we meet all the celebrities and know all the dancers because some celebs think they know better,” Katz explained. The pairing attempts to create harmony, ensuring that all partners can work well together, which is essential for both the competitors and the audience.
The show also welcomes contestants who have their own visions for partners. Recent winner Joey Graziadei revealed that he requested a partner who was in a stable relationship, aware of how personal dynamics can influence the experience on the show. He expressed, “I didn’t want there to be any chance of noise on this because I know that comes with the show and the territory sometimes.” His sentiments highlight a common consideration among participants regarding the social challenges that can accompany fame.
Another facet of the selection process is matching dancers based on physical compatibility. Ballas explained that height and size are taken into account to ensure comfort while dancing. Personality compatibility is also crucial, as each professional has a unique teaching style and approach to choreography. This attention to detail ensures that both the celebrities and dancers are well-matched in more than just skill.
Alfonso Ribeiro, co-host of the show and winner of season 19, expressed his confidence in Katz’s capabilities. He referred to her as the magic behind successful pairings. Ribeiro emphasised that Katz does not simply follow a formula; she engages with the personalities involved, allowing her heart to guide her decisions. “She knows exactly how to pair them up,” he said, articulating her intuitive approach to matchmaking that results in stunning performances.
As the premiere date draws near, it is clear that the success of “Dancing with the Stars” hinges on the careful curation of its contestant pairings. With the creative vision of Deena Katz and a diverse array of talented dancers and celebrities, Season 35 promises to deliver captivating moments that honour the spirit of the beloved competition. The combination of talent and artistry in dance continues to captivate audiences, ensuring that each season brings fresh excitement—and magic—to the ballroom.