Shailene Woodley has recently opened up about her experience as Mary Jane Watson in the much-discussed The Amazing Spider-Man 2, revealing that her scenes were ultimately cut from the film. The actress reflected on this lost opportunity during her appearance at the SAG-AFTRA Foundation’s Conversations event on 11 August.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Shailene-Woodley-083126-34afd921bb3d45e4aeb21ae9d1e8cbc1.jpg)
Woodley, who is renowned for her roles in films such as The Fault in Our Stars and the Divergent series, expressed disappointment over the news she received a year after filming her scenes alongside Andrew Garfield, who played Spider-Man. “I was cast as Mary Jane for Spider-Man, which was my dream. Oh my god, Spider-Man’s my favourite superhero; Mary Jane was my favourite character growing up,” she recalled. Her excitement turned to confusion when she learned that her footage would not make it into the final cut.
The actress elaborated on the decision, explaining that after filming three scenes with Garfield, producers contacted her to inform her that her role had been scrapped. The rationale given was that the film’s focus had shifted towards Peter Parker’s relationship with Gwen Stacy, portrayed by Emma Stone. Woodley quipped about the situation, remarking, “That was a fun phone call,” highlighting her disbelief and surprise at the news.
Woodley explained that the filmmakers felt it would be best to delay the introduction of Mary Jane until after they resolved Peter’s relationship with Gwen. “They were like, ‘Let’s wait for her to die, and then we’ll introduce Mary Jane,’” she said. This clearly outlined a strategy to centralise the emotional impact of Peter and Gwen’s story before branching out to include other characters. However, plans for a third film in the series were ultimately shelved after The Amazing Spider-Man 2 underperformed at the box office, leaving no opportunity for Woodley’s Mary Jane to appear onscreen.
The saga of The Amazing Spider-Man series began back in 2012, when Garfield donned the Spider-Man suit for the first time. The initial film tells the story of Peter Parker as he grapples with discovering his powers while also looking into the mystery of his parents’ disappearance. The sequel, released in 2014, delves deeper into his relationship with Gwen, complicating their romance with the introduction of new villains such as Electro and Harry Osborn.
In a heartbreaking turn of events, Gwen’s tragic death in the sequel marks a pivotal moment for Peter Parker, momentarily forcing him to step back from his role as Spider-Man. This emotional climax was expected to pave the way for a potential introduction of Woodley as Mary Jane in future installments, a plan that, unfortunately, never materialised.
The younger Spidey films have evolved significantly since Woodley was cast. Zendaya has taken up the iconic role of MJ in Marvel’s ongoing series, debuting alongside Tom Holland in 2017’s Spider-Man: Homecoming. Her portrayal and development of the character have been well received, solidifying her place in the franchise and creating a new dynamic with Holland’s Peter Parker.
While Woodley expressed her hesitance to discuss her experiences with the Spider-Man franchise over the years, she acknowledged the puzzling nature of her casting: “I’m so paranoid… It’s been out for over 10 years, Shailene.” The actress candidly reflected on how long she has held back from addressing this chapter of her career, perhaps indicative of the lingering impact it still has on her.
Director Marc Webb also commented on the situation at the time, affirming Woodley’s talent and the disappointment of having to cut her scenes. “Shailene is an incredibly talented actress,” he stated, acknowledging the emotional complexities that come with such decisions in filmmaking.
In a twist of fate, Garfield later reprised his role as Spider-Man in the recent hit, Spider-Man: No Way Home. This film restored fans’ interest in the character and reunited Garfield with other Spider-Man actors, further solidifying the franchise’s ability to evolve beyond its previous iterations.
As fans continue to reminisce about The Amazing Spider-Man series, Woodley’s candid insights serve as a reminder of the unpredictable nature of film production and the shifting creative landscapes that can alter the course of beloved stories. The earlier films in the series, including The Amazing Spider-Man and its sequel, are currently available for streaming on Disney+, allowing audiences to revisit the cinematic journey that continues to inspire both nostalgia and speculation.