Gail Simmons Reveals Which “Top Chef” Judge Is Most Likely to Cry if the Show Wins an Emmy: ‘Cries About Everything’ (Exclusive)

**‘Top Chef’ Judges Share Emotional Stories Ahead of Emmy Nominations**

As the popular culinary competition show “Top Chef” gears up for the 2026 Emmy Awards, the judges are opening up about their experiences on the show and their mutual admiration for one another. With the series nominated for Outstanding Reality Competition Program, among other accolades, emotions are running high. Judge Gail Simmons has shared insights into her fellow judges’ personalities, highlighting Kristen Kish’s potential emotional response should they win the coveted award.

Simmons, who has been a prominent figure on “Top Chef,” believes that Kish, the show’s host, is the most likely judge to shed tears if they were to receive an Emmy. “Kristen cries at everything,” Simmons remarked, reflecting on Kish’s heartfelt nature. “I think we’d all cry, but she’s quite the outspoken crier.”

Kish herself expressed her joy regarding the Emmy nomination, noting her feelings of pride for both herself and the show. “It feels amazing,” she said. The recognition of not just the show but also categories such as directing and casting is a significant moment for the cast and crew. Kish revealed her enthusiastic reaction upon learning of the nominations, exclaiming, “When the outstanding show plus directing plus casting nominations all rolled in, I was like, ‘f— yeah.’ All well deserved.”

Simmons commended Kish for bringing a unique “empathy factor” to the series since her time as a contestant. She noted how Kish has evolved over the past three years in her role as host while managing to stay true to herself. “She still wears her sweatpants and her hat backwards and prefers flip-flops to nice shoes,” Simmons commented. “She’s still a completely humble person, but she possesses a strong sense of self and style.”

This sentiment reflects a broader admiration among the judges for one another. As they continue to grow both professionally and personally, the connection they share strengthens. “It’s just amazing to watch someone that you admire so much come into their own,” Simmons remarked about Kish. “We’ve all changed a lot since she’s come on the show, and that’s directly due to her.”

However, Kish is not the only judge known for her emotions. Tom Colicchio, another esteemed judge on the panel, has surprised Simmons with his depth of empathy. She affectionately referred to him as her “roommate” while noting how he continues to challenge the gruff persona often associated with him on the show. “He’s not the grumpy person that people think he is,” Simmons explained. “He’s serious about food and the chefs but is also a loyal friend.”

Colicchio’s emotional side shone through during a recent birthday celebration for Simmons, where he delivered a heartfelt speech. “I’ve been sitting in this chair for 20 years, and it is the place I am the most comfortable with the two people that I love the most in the world, besides my family,” he said, referencing Simmons and Kish. The moment left a deep impression on those present, further showcasing the camaraderie that exists among the judges.

Speaking about Kish, Colicchio expressed admiration for how well she has taken on the hosting responsibilities while upholding the show’s standards. “I think she’s getting so much recognition for her hosting job and hopefully she’ll win,” he remarked. He praised her resolve and enthusiasm, especially her lively representation of the show on social media.

The chemistry between the three judges is apparent, and they all acknowledge the fun they have together while working on “Top Chef.” Colicchio reminisced about an instance where Kish highlighted the show’s absence from a social media post featuring fan-favourite programmes. “She said, ‘What about Top Chef?’” he recalled with a laugh, emphasizing Kish’s passion for ensuring their show receives the recognition it deserves.

With all the nomination excitement building up, the future looks bright for “Top Chef.” Each judge brings their unique qualities and emotional intelligence to the show, enhancing the viewing experience for audiences. As they prepare for the Emmys, their shared memories and support for one another stand as a testament to the meaningful relationships they have forged throughout their time on the programme.

In a world often dominated by competitive spirit, the judges of “Top Chef” demonstrate that camaraderie, empathy, and mutual respect are what truly make a show remarkable. As the Emmys draw near, fans will be watching closely to see how the team fares, and perhaps, in true Kish fashion, there will be tears of joy if their hard work is recognised with an award.