Jonathan Bennett and Benjamin Ayres Reveal the Most Important Traits for a Hallmark Heartthrob (Exclusive)

**Jonathan Bennett and Benjamin Ayres Discuss the Essence of Hallmark Leading Men**

Leading actors Jonathan Bennett and Benjamin Ayres are well-acquainted with the charm and unique appeal of Hallmark films, having graced the network with their performances for many years. As Hallmark approaches its 25th anniversary, the two actors shared their insights into what makes a Hallmark leading man resonate with audiences during an interview on August 4, in New York City.

Bennett embarked on his Hallmark journey in 2010, while Ayres joined in 2016. Both have actively contributed to the network’s reputation for feel-good storytelling, particularly in the realm of festive romances. They recently participated in a celebration of Hallmark Channel’s enduring presence in the world of television, where they reflected on their roles and the impact they hope to make through their performances.

Ayres highlighted the significance of vulnerability in connecting with viewers, stating, “Vulnerability is crucial. It’s not easy to be charming and funny, but finding moments of vulnerability allows the audience to form a real connection.” He elaborated on how his ability to tap into these emotional experiences aids not only in his performance but also in the overall portrayal of his characters.

The actor’s filmography includes several beloved Christmas-themed productions, such as the upcoming *The Santa Class* set for release in 2024, and *Miracle in Bethlehem, PA* from 2023. One of his recent roles saw him star alongside Meghan Ory in *A Christmas Angel Match*. In this film, Ayres plays Michael, who, along with his Christmas angel partner, aims to unite two destined souls before the holiday.

For Bennett, the key characteristics of a leading man extend beyond vulnerability. “Authenticity is paramount, both as an actor and a person,” he stated. He contends that when actors are genuine in their depiction of characters, it forms a compelling concoction that resonates deeply with audiences. Bennett expressed pride in portraying diversity on screen, particularly as he played Hallmark’s first leading man in a same-sex relationship.

The groundbreaking role saw Bennett making history in 2020 when he participated in Hallmark’s first same-sex kiss in *The Christmas House*. His continued dedication to representation was further cemented with the 2022 release of *The Holiday Sitter*, which he co-wrote and also executive produced. This film marked Hallmark’s first gay Christmas movie, showcasing Bennett’s commitment to expanding the narrative possibilities within the network.

Bennett elaborated on the diversity of leading roles available today, asserting, “Leading men can embody different identities—be they straight or gay—and still captivate audiences. The spectrum of representation is vast.” He believes that portraying authentic characters, irrespective of their sexual orientation, enriches the audience’s viewing experience and reflects societal shifts towards greater acceptance and inclusivity.

As they approach a pivotal moment in Hallmark’s history, both actors are enthusiastic about the network’s evolution and its commitment to diverse storytelling. They see their roles not just as performances but as opportunities to foster connections and represent broader narratives within romantic storytelling.

Fans of Hallmark can look forward to enjoying the duo’s work as they continue to star in heartwarming films that capture the essence of love and togetherness. The upcoming titles promise to deliver the same festive magic that Hallmark audiences cherish, ensuring that the legacy of feel-good television lives on.

In embracing both vulnerability and authenticity, Bennett and Ayres embody the spirit of what it means to be a Hallmark leading man. Their performances remind viewers that, while the stories may be lighthearted, the values of connection and genuine emotion are at the heart of every tale told.

As Hallmark continues to celebrate its legacy, the contributions of actors like Bennett and Ayres serve as a testament to the network’s ongoing commitment to storytelling that resonates deeply with its audience. For those wishing to experience this wealth of narratives, many films featuring these talented actors are currently available on Hallmark+.