The Investigation Discovery docuseries, ‘Game Day Murders,’ revisits one of the most astonishing cases in National Hockey League (NHL) history, focusing on former St. Louis Blues player Mike Danton. Danton’s professional hockey career came to an abrupt halt in 2004 when he became embroiled in a murder-for-hire scandal, an incident that has since captivated and bewildered sports fans and criminal justice observers alike.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Mike-Danton-of-the-St-Louis-Blues-080526-22116215b8e74cee9ab190481b6233a9.jpg)
On 15 April 2004, Danton played a pivotal role in his team’s playoff game against the San Jose Sharks, scoring a goal in what would ultimately be his final match of the season. However, just hours later, as the Blues were eliminated from the postseason, FBI agents arrested him in connection with a conspiracy to commit murder. This shocking turn of events sent ripples throughout the sporting world and altered the trajectory of Danton’s life.
Two decades later, ‘Game Day Murders’ revisits the extraordinary tale, particularly highlighting a bizarre twist: one of the spectators at that playoff game soon became a critical figure in the subsequent investigation. The docuseries, hosted by veteran sportscaster Lindsay Czarniak and produced by basketball legend Shaquille O’Neal, delves into six notorious incidents where sports intersect with violent crime. The second episode, titled “Ice Cold Conspiracy,” sheds light on Danton’s case, described by Czarniak as one of the most scandalous in professional sports history.
“In the history of the NHL, there has never been a story as shocking,” Czarniak remarked in the episode, emphasising the severity of Danton’s actions. Retired FBI Special Agent John Jimenez, who was present at the playoff game when Danton scored, shared his astonishment at the unfolding events. “I would have never imagined that within the next 72 hours, I would be involved in a case investigating him,” he reflected, calling it “the strangest case” he had ever worked on.
The narrative of Danton’s career is unpicked in the episode, detailing his ascent as one of Canada’s top hockey prospects and his evolution into an NHL player known for his aggressive style. However, the documentary also examines the complexities of his upbringing, including a troubled relationship with his estranged father and the influence of controversial agent David Frost, who had taken Danton under his wing at a young age.
Although Danton was not convicted of murder, he pleaded guilty to conspiracy related to the plot, which prosecutors claimed was aimed at Frost. In a twist, Danton later asserted that the intended target was in fact his estranged father. According to legal documents, the plot involved a 19-year-old college volleyball player, Katie Wolfmeyer, who unknowingly introduced Danton to an undercover police officer posing as a hitman.
This shocking allegation took place while the Blues were preoccupied with their playoff series. The individual identified as the supposed assassin, Justin Levi Jones, was a police dispatcher who promptly reported Danton’s intentions to the authorities. Jones subsequently collaborated with the FBI as their investigation progressed.
The circumstances surrounding the scandal left a lasting impression on those who covered the sport. Sports columnist Steve Simmons commented on the intensity of Danton’s ambition, stating, “If you’re Mike Danton, your entire life is about nothing more than making the NHL… and in the middle of all this, he’s making a phone call to have someone murdered.” Simmons further recounted Danton’s former esteem, highlighting his status as one of the top hockey talents in Toronto by the age of 16.
Danton was ultimately charged with conspiracy to utilise interstate commerce facilities in committing murder for hire. He accepted a plea deal and was sentenced to seven-and-a-half years in federal prison, serving over five years before being released on parole in 2009. At the age of 45, Danton has not provided commentary for the docuseries, a notable absence given the gravity of his story.
Wolfmeyer, the college player who connected Danton to the alleged hitman, also faced legal repercussions, being charged with two counts linked to the conspiracy. She was acquitted on both charges after facing trial.
The episode “Ice Cold Conspiracy” is currently available for viewing on Investigation Discovery, with new episodes of ‘Game Day Murders’ airing weekly. Those interested in revisiting this extraordinary and perplexing case can also find episodes available for streaming on platforms like HBO Max. The documentary serves as a stark reminder of the unpredictable chaos that can sometimes arise in the thrilling world of professional sports.