A tragic chapter in Wisconsin’s history remains etched in the memories of many as 19-year-old theatre student Jessie Blodgett was murdered over a decade ago, an event that left her community and loved ones reeling. Blodgett was found strangled in her home on July 14, 2013, after attending a cast party for a production of *Fiddler on the Roof*. Her death was unexpected and shocking, both to her family and her peers at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, where she was a sophomore studying theatre.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Jessie-Blodgett-dan-bartelt-071825-72a9314bb98b4a25802a12c0929a615c.jpg)
Daniel Bartelt, a former boyfriend and friend of Blodgett, was subsequently arrested and charged with her murder after a quick investigation. He was apprehended 16 days following the discovery of Blodgett’s body, but Bartelt has consistently maintained his innocence throughout the legal proceedings.
On the evening of her death, Blodgett returned home late from the cast party, only to be found lifeless by her mother the next day. Authorities noted signs of strangulation but struggled to identify a murder weapon. A search of Blodgett’s digital footprints revealed her involvement in her theatre community, with posts about her performances on social media. An autopsy later confirmed that her death was the result of strangulation, intensifying the urgency of the investigation.
Blodgett and Bartelt shared a long-standing friendship that dated back to high school. Their relationship had evolved over the years — they had dated briefly before becoming close friends. Bartelt had even arrived at Blodgett’s home shortly after her death under the guise of offering support, a move that further complicated the investigation. His interactions with Blodgett’s family prior to his arrest raised suspicions regarding his involvement in her murder.
Compounding the complexity of the situation, it was revealed that just days before Blodgett’s murder, Bartelt had attacked a woman in a nearby park, wielding a knife. Although the victim managed to disarm him, this incident brought his actions into question. In the wake of Blodgett’s murder, police scrutinised Bartelt’s behaviour and uncovered significant evidence linking him to the crime.
While being interviewed, Bartelt inadvertently mentioned details of the case that had not yet been released to the public. This included the statement that Blodgett had been “raped and murdered,” which raised immediate red flags for the investigators. They subsequently retrieved surveillance footage showing Bartelt in a park close to the crime scene at the time of her death. Items of evidence including binding materials were later discovered in a nearby rubbish bin, distinctly tying him to the murder.
Though Bartelt refrained from explaining his motives, during his sentencing hearing he claimed, “I can’t give you the reasons you are looking for,” maintaining his innocence. The prosecution argued that his rekindled interest in Blodgett turned dangerous after she spurned his advances. This assertion was compounded by testimony from friends who noted his professed interest in her.
Bartelt faced multiple charges, including first-degree intentional homicide, as well as charges stemming from the attack on the woman in the park. On August 19, 2014, he was found guilty of Blodgett’s murder, and on October 14, he was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Bartelt currently resides in the Waupun Correctional Institution, continuing to assert his innocence.
The presiding judge at the trial, Todd Martens, expressed the gravity of the crime when he declared that the impact of such brutality meant Blodgett’s family deserved reassurance that Bartelt would never threaten another life. Buck Blodgett, Jessie’s father, even extended a sentiment of forgiveness to Bartelt, albeit complicated by the deep pain his family endured. He stated, “I not only forgive you, I love you,” explaining that this was a reflection of the values he wished to uphold in the face of tragedy.
In the years following Jessie Blodgett’s death, her legacy has thrived. In 2016, her father founded the “Love Is Greater Than Hate Project,” honouring Jessie’s commitment to raising awareness about male violence against women. Buck described her as an outspoken advocate for this cause, which underscores the importance of continuing the dialogue surrounding violence and safety.
As Jessie Blodgett’s story continues to evoke strong emotions and remembrance, it serves as a sobering reminder of the issues women face regarding violence. Her life and untimely death impacted many, reinforcing the notion that greater understanding and prevention of such tragedies is vital for future generations.