Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen have recently reached a critical juncture in a tumultuous legal dispute that has garnered significant media attention. The former couple has been embroiled in allegations of domestic violence and an ongoing custody battle since March. This high-profile case revolves around their two-year-old son, Ever.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Taylor-Frankie-Paul-Dakota-Mortensen-031826-5a2b34d6f3734f208c8863b5ab88d619.jpg)

On June 1, a judge made a pivotal ruling that modified the existing custody arrangements between Paul and Mortensen. The updated order allows Paul to have unsupervised parenting time with Ever, a significant shift from the previous stipulations that mandated supervision during her visitations. The judge also formalised a schedule where Paul can see her son midweek without overnight stays, in addition to alternating weekend custody. Notably, Mortensen will continue to serve as the custodial parent during holidays.
A directive was issued by the judge, prohibiting both parents from sharing unflattering remarks about each other, particularly on social media platforms. This decree underscores the court’s intention to shield the young child from the ongoing animosity between the two parents and aims to promote a more constructive co-parenting dynamic.

The current legal modifications follow an extended period of heated disputes, which began in February when allegations of violence were exchanged between Paul and Mortensen. Both parties reported incidents to Utah police, prompting investigations into their respective claims. In the wake of these allegations, Mortensen sought a protective order against Paul, to which Paul responded by requesting her own protective order. The court granted both orders for a duration of three years during a hearing on April 30.
Prior to this latest hearing, the court had already granted Mortensen primary custody of Ever. At that time, Paul was allowed supervised visitation for up to eight hours each week with a designated supervisor, reflecting the court’s concerns about the potentially volatile circumstances surrounding the couple. The court chose to uphold this arrangement during the April hearing, indicating the serious nature of the allegations and the resulting need for caution.
The accusations between the two have taken a severe turn, with Paul alleging that Mortensen stalked her and assaulted her during an altercation, while Mortensen has presented evidence of injuries he claims to have sustained during their disputes. Last year, Paul herself was arrested following an alleged domestic violence incident involving Mortensen, where she faced accusations of throwing chairs during a confrontation with him in the presence of her daughter. Ultimately, Paul entered a guilty plea in abeyance to charges of aggravated assault, following an agreement with prosecutors.
The dramatic circumstances of their relationship and legal challenges were further compounded by the release of a video capturing one of their altercations, which came to public attention in March. The footage showed Paul engaging in aggressive behaviour towards Mortensen, leading to significant media backlash. The fallout was such that ABC cancelled Paul’s already completed season of “The Bachelorette,” although executives have hinted that it may eventually be aired.
As the legal battles unfolded, production on the fifth season of “Mormon Wives” was temporarily halted due to cast members voicing their reluctance to work with Paul amidst the ongoing turmoil. Subsequently, producers have confirmed that filming for the series is resuming, but with a focus only on new confessionals for the upcoming season—indicating that the production team is keen to navigate the controversy carefully.
The next custody hearing for the couple is scheduled for July 8, when they will return to court to address ongoing issues regarding their son’s care and welfare. The continued attention on this case serves as a reminder of the impact such disputes can have on family dynamics and the lives of those involved, especially young children caught in the crossfire.
For anyone experiencing domestic violence, support is available through the National Domestic Violence Hotline, which offers confidential assistance 24 hours a day in multiple languages. The hotline can be reached in the UK by calling 0808 2000 247 or via their website.
