An upcoming episode of the renowned television series *Antiques Roadshow* is set to explore the valuation of an American Girl doll, stirring a lively debate among fans regarding whether the doll qualifies as an ‘antique’ and the accuracy of its appraised worth. The episode features Molly McIntire, a model that holds sentimental value for many collectors, including the guest who presented the doll, a woman known as Sarah Jean.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/american-girl-molly-050126-ff13238a38984c2fb6884c581ba786c8.jpg)
The clip, shared by *Antiques Roadshow*, showcases Jean discussing her prized possession with expert appraiser Brigid Jones from McHughs LLC. During an event held at Grant’s Farm in St. Louis, Missouri, Jean recounted her experience of purchasing the doll around 25 to 30 years ago at a warehouse sale held by the Pleasant Company in Middleton, Wisconsin. This company was the original producer of American Girl dolls before being acquired by Mattel in 1998.
Jean revealed that her doll purchase was not just a casual acquisition, but part of a memorable event. She attended the sale with her mother and best friend’s mother, sharing fond memories of a chaotic atmosphere filled with eager collectors. Jean was particularly drawn to Molly due to her distinctive braids, glasses, and bangs, a look she still embraces today. Remarkably, she mentioned that she only paid $50 for the doll at that time, a figure that has since elicited astonishment among viewers of the show.
Established in 1986, the Pleasant Company initially launched with three dolls: Kirsten Larson, Samantha Parkington, and Molly. These dolls were designed to reflect historical periods, with Molly depicted as a child living through World War II and navigating the challenges of wartime life. In discussing the importance of her doll, Jones noted that the original versions of these dolls were crafted in Germany, which adds value to Jean’s earlier model. She specified that Jean’s doll is an early example, identifiable by its white torso fabric and its “Made in West Germany” tag.
During the appraisal, Jones valued the doll at approximately £1,000 to £1,200, citing its historical significance and the care Jean has taken to preserve it. However, this valuation sparked controversy in the comments section of the video, with some users questioning whether the doll could truly be seen as an antique and suggesting that its worth would require additional accessories to match the appraised figure.
Jean herself later took to the comments to defend her childhood attachment to the doll. She emphasised that her devotion extended beyond mere play; it involved creating stories and nurturing a deep appreciation for Molly’s character. In her response, she urged critics to recognise the emotional connection children form with their toys and the importance of loving and caring for them.
The American Girl brand is marking its 40th anniversary this year, having expanded its lineup to include numerous characters reflecting diverse periods and backgrounds. Notably, the introduction of Felicity Merriman, a girl from the American Revolution, and Addy Walker, the company’s first Black doll who illustrated the struggle for freedom in the era of slavery, showcased a commitment to representing a broad spectrum of American experiences.
In celebration of its anniversary, American Girl is also releasing a new book titled *The Making of American Girl*, which traces the evolution of the brand from its inception to present day. This publication highlights Pleasant T. Rowland’s vision of using play as a medium for teaching history, alongside the narrative development provided by her colleague Valerie Tripp. The effort aims to educate children about resilience through the stories of the dolls, which present historical challenges alongside themes of triumph.
Following Mattel’s acquisition of the brand for $700 million, the American Girl line has grown to include 25 historical dolls and several contemporary new releases, including the Girl of the Year series. To commemorate four decades of storytelling, the brand has reintroduced its original eight historical dolls alongside plans for new narratives that continue the legacy of empowerment and education through play.
*Antiques Roadshow* continues to draw viewers with its appraisal of unique items, shining a light on the rich histories behind them. It airs on Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on PBS and is available on the PBS app, captivating audiences keen to explore the hidden stories within their belongings.