Cole Brings Plenty Starred in a “Yellowstone” Spinoff Before He Disappeared. Inside His Mysterious Death

In April 2024, tragedy struck the entertainment community with the death of Cole Brings Plenty, the promising young actor known for his role as Pete Plenty Clouds in the series *1923*. Cole was the nephew of Mo Brings Plenty, a familiar face in the popular shows *Yellowstone* and *Marshals*. His death, which occurred just days after he was reported missing and had been named a suspect in a domestic violence incident, left a significant mark on both his family and fans alike.

The circumstances surrounding Cole’s disappearance raised alarms among his loved ones, particularly as he missed an important appointment with his agent, behaviour they considered uncharacteristic. Following his absence, his uncle, Mo, took to social media to share a missing persons poster, highlighting the urgency of the situation. Shortly after, the Lawrence Police Department announced they were investigating a domestic violence claim linked to Cole, following reports of a woman in distress at an apartment complex on the morning he vanished. Surveillance footage purportedly showed him leaving the city soon after the alleged incident, prompting police to identify him as a suspect.

Tragically, Cole’s body was discovered just a few days later, hidden in a wooded area in rural Kansas. Law enforcement officials revealed that his vehicle was found nearby, and the discovery was described in a press release that confirmed the identity of the deceased. While his family initially sought answers, two years on from this devastating loss, questions about the handling of the investigation into Cole’s death remain contentious.

Mo Brings Plenty has spoken openly about the lack of thorough investigation into his nephew’s case, expressing his heartache over what he perceives as a failure of the justice system. He expressed frustration that authorities quickly dismissed the circumstances surrounding Cole’s death, claiming that the case was written off with a statement of “no foul play.” This sentiment fuelled his belief that more could have been done to investigate the events leading to Cole’s tragic end.

In response to Mo’s claims, a spokesperson for the Lawrence Police Department asserted that they had conducted a comprehensive investigation, presenting their findings to Cole’s family. They noted that the family had requested to keep certain details of the case sealed, including the autopsy report, which has contributed to ongoing speculation about the nature of his death. The spokesperson affirmed that evidence indicated no foul play, asserting that Cole had acted alone, while indicating their willingness to share more details should the family permit it.

The Johnson County Sheriff’s Office echoed similar sentiments, stating they undertook an exhaustive review of the case and disclosed what they found to Cole’s family. Despite the assurances from law enforcement, the tragic incident has left many unanswered questions, which continues to haunt those who cared for Cole.

Over the past two years, Cole Brings Plenty has not been forgotten, as various productions within the Taylor Sheridan universe have paid tribute to him. His legacy was honoured in February 2025 during the second season premiere of *1923*, where a tribute message featuring a photo of Cole was shared. This initial acknowledgment was a gesture meant to commemorate his contribution to the show, though it was soon revealed that his role would be recast.

Most recently, the April 5 episode of *Marshals* provided another poignant memorial for Cole, coinciding with a storyline that focused on remembrance for another character, Monica. Arielle Kebbel, who stars in *Marshals*, revealed that the filming of this episode held a profound emotional significance for the cast and crew. Mo Brings Plenty attended the set during this episode’s production, bringing his family along for what proved to be an emotionally charged day, emphasising the overlapping boundaries between artistic representation and personal grief.

The ongoing tributes serve as a reminder of the void Cole’s passing has left, highlighting the impact of his work and the relationships he built. Cole Brings Plenty’s journey was tragically cut short, yet his memory continues to resonate within a community of creators and fans who mourn his loss while celebrating his life and contributions to the world of television.