The latest episode of the series “Love Story,” which explores the tumultuous romance between John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette Kennedy, has ignited conversations surrounding the fashion choices of its lead character. Portrayed by Sarah Pidgeon, Carolyn’s understated yet sophisticated style is integral to her characterisation, sparking interest among viewers and fashion enthusiasts alike.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/sarah-pigeon-love-story-030226-1-e1f75d9e835b4a65bb77b41d5e040c70.jpg)

In Episode 4, titled “I Love You,” a significant moment arises when Carolyn shares the meaning behind a simple chain necklace that features a wedding band. Initially claiming that the ring belonged to her father, this detail has proved controversial as historical accounts suggest it was, in fact, her mother’s wedding band. The show uses this necklace as a symbol of Carolyn’s complex views on love and relationships, raising questions about its accuracy.
Throughout the series, Carolyn’s fashion reflects her penchant for minimalism, creating an aesthetic that paints a vivid picture of her real-life counterpart. Costume designer Rudy Mance has ensured that the looks are not flamboyant, staying true to Carolyn’s preference for subtlety over ostentation. The show’s careful curation of Carolyn’s style seeks to encapsulate her real-life tendency to forgo jewellery, further highlighting her unique elegance.

The emotional weight of the necklace is revealed after Carolyn spends the night at JFK Jr.’s loft. During a conversation, she clarifies that the necklace serves as a poignant reminder of her father’s ambiguous nature rather than a token of affection. “I don’t wear this because I love my father. I wear this to remind me that what he seemed to be, he wasn’t,” Carolyn states, reflecting her cautious stance towards relationships. This insight offers a deeper understanding of her character and her guarded emotions.
However, the discrepancies regarding the origin of the ring have raised eyebrows. Carolyn’s parents, William and Ann Bessette Kennedy, divorced when she was just eight, leading to her father’s absence during her formative years. This backstory complicates Carolyn’s feelings as she navigates her new relationship with JFK Jr. An article from WWD discusses how JFK Jr. encouraged Carolyn to reconnect with her father later in life, hinting at the complexity of their familial ties.
Jewellery historian Marion Fasel, in her Substack, The Adventurine, underscores that the band likely belonged to Carolyn’s mother. This distinction sheds light on possible motivations behind the show’s narrative choices. By attributing the ring to her father, the series may aim to enhance Carolyn’s emotional conflict regarding her and JFK Jr.’s relationship, particularly as she grapples with her past.
Moreover, Sunita Kumar Nair’s book “CBK: Carolyn Bessette Kennedy: A Life in Fashion” discusses Carolyn’s affection for her mother’s jewellery. It highlights a scene where Carolyn jokes about needing to “dip it in holy water,” a quirky nod to her parents’ divorce. This relationship with her mother’s belongings is suggestive of the deep emotional significance they held for Carolyn, adding layers to her character that are worthy of exploration in the narrative.
As “Love Story” continues to draw viewers in with its mix of historical intrigue and fashion, the portrayal of Carolyn Bessette Kennedy serves as a focal point for discussions about identity, familial relationships, and the complexities of love. The series, while dramatized, aims to highlight the nuances of its characters’ lives, and the ongoing conversation about Carolyn’s symbols, especially her necklace, reflects the careful attention to detail by its creators.
The relationship of Carolyn and JFK Jr. remains a subject of fascination, not only for its romantic elements but also for the poignant intersections of love and family dynamics that are presented in both the series and Carolyn’s real life. As audiences continue to engage with the show, it is likely that the dialogue around Carolyn’s portrayal and style will evolve, reflecting the lasting impact of her legacy on both fashion and culture.
