An Illinois nurse, Sarah A. Delashmit, gained notoriety after it was revealed that she had not only faked various serious health conditions but had also manipulated friendships to garner sympathy and support. Following her actions, which have been described as exploitative and deceitful, Delashmit was convicted and sentenced for her crimes.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Sarah-Delashmit-021926-2-708eb697ff9647a190133b774ec20a8b.jpg)
The extraordinary story of Delashmit, detailed in the recent episode of Investigation Discovery’s series *The Curious Case Of…*, highlights her time as a camp counselor at a summer camp for adults with disabilities. It was there that she developed a close bond with Erin Johnson, a woman with cerebral palsy. Their friendship, which blossomed in 2005, took a troubling turn as Delashmit began fabricating a narrative around her health.
Johnson, who attended the camp, recounted how Delashmit expressed curiosity about her disability, asking numerous questions that led Johnson to believe she was genuinely interested in understanding her experiences. Delashmit subsequently claimed to have various ailments, including cancer and miscarriages, deepening their connection through these shared struggles.
However, the friendship spiralled into a web of deceit when Delashmit fabricated a story about her non-existent sister, Gabby, who she alleged suffered from muscular dystrophy. Johnson later learned that Gabby was merely a figment of Delashmit’s imagination, a shocking revelation that left her feeling betrayed and hurt. The story took another unsettling twist when, years later, Delashmit was discovered standing unaided during a visit from her family at a camp in Texas, despite previously claiming to use a wheelchair due to muscular dystrophy.
Bethany Turner, another camp counsellor who became close to Delashmit, shared her disbelief upon learning of Delashmit’s deception. Turner recalled the frequent assistance she provided to Delashmit regarding her mobility, which made the truth all the more astonishing. “She was able-bodied and was lying about all of this,” Turner stated, expressing her shock at the betrayal.
The dramatic revelations prompted Erin Johnson to confront Delashmit, asking her directly why she had fabricated such elaborate stories over the years. Delashmit’s vague response only added to the betrayal, as Johnson struggled to comprehend why her friend would resort to such deceit after sharing significant portions of their lives together.
Legal experts have weighed in on the case, with analyst Beth Karas condemning Delashmit’s actions as not only stealing emotions but also robbing individuals of their trust and time. She remarked on the extensive damage inflicted on those who believed Delashmit’s fabricated stories, particularly considering the sensitive nature of the medical conditions she pretended to have.
Delashmit’s fabrications extended beyond her interactions with Johnson and Turner. She had reportedly misled charitable organisations and individuals about having stage IV breast cancer, using these lies to obtain donations and support from unwitting sympathisers. In one incident, she accepted a bike donation under false pretences, claiming to be a cancer survivor, only for the authorities to discover she purchased another bike using her mother’s credit card without permission.
Following a comprehensive investigation led by local officials and the FBI, Delashmit was indicted in 2020 on multiple counts, including wire fraud and aggravated identity theft. She pleaded guilty and was subsequently sentenced in 2021 to 18 months in federal prison, as well as three years of supervised release. Additionally, she was ordered to repay over £7,000 to the organisations she defrauded and pay fines for her deceitful behaviour.
Released in 2022, Delashmit has since moved back in with her mother and started a family, having welcomed a baby and joined a local mothers’ group. While she did not participate in the documentary that chronicled her story, the impact of her actions continues to resonate with those she deceived.
The saga of Sarah A. Delashmit raises pertinent questions about trust and the exploitation of vulnerable communities. Her actions have shocked friends and advocates alike, prompting many to urge increased vigilance against similar fraudulent schemes that prey on the goodwill of others. The case serves as a stark reminder of the importance of integrity and honesty, especially within healthcare professions that rely on trust.