A New York City man, Nicholas McGee, has been sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for the brutal murder and dismemberment of his acquaintance, Kawsheen Gelzer. The harrowing attack took place in March 2022, where McGee, aged 48, stabbed Gelzer, 38, more than 60 times and even struck him with a hammer. Following the gruesome murder, McGee proceeded to dismember Gelzer’s body before stashing the remains in his fridge and freezer. This heinous crime shocked the residents of Flatbush and left authorities reeling with horror at the extent of the brutality displayed by the perpetrator.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/nicolas-mcgee-Kashween-Gelzer-112625-89c3371d5f274d22b2a6f482337254a4.jpg)
The sentencing, which was delivered on November 19, comes after a jury found McGee guilty of first-degree murder and concealing a human corpse. Prosecutors revealed that the murder took place in the apartment shared by McGee, Gelzer, and McGee’s wife, Heather Stines. The barbarity of the crime is further highlighted by the fact that Gelzer’s remains were stored in separate plastic bags within the apartment’s appliances after he was dismembered by McGee. It was not until January 20, 2024 when an anonymous tip led the police to McGee’s residence that the horrifying truth came to light.
McGee’s actions following the murder only add to the chilling nature of the crime. Reports indicate that he went through Gelzer’s pockets, taking the drugs Gelzer had on him to use with Stines. The motive for this brutal act stemmed from a drug-related dispute, as confirmed in a sentencing memo retrieved by the New York Daily News. The details of the memo shed light on the events leading up to the murder, indicating Gelzer’s previous interactions with the couple, which ultimately culminated in this gruesome tragedy.
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez commented on the case, expressing his shock and disgust at the cruelty displayed by McGee. The district attorney described the act as not just a theft of life but also a desecration of Gelzer’s body, showcasing a callous disregard for human life. As the legal proceedings continued, Stines, McGee’s wife, pleaded guilty to concealing a human corpse and third-degree bail jumping in October 2024. Her sentencing is yet to take place, leaving authorities to unravel the full extent of the couple’s involvement in this horrific crime.
The revelation of Gelzer’s murder and the subsequent legal proceedings have sent shockwaves through the community, prompting reflection on the fragile nature of human life and the capacity for unfathomable evil that exists in society. The meticulous planning and execution of such a horrific crime have left many questioning the depths of depravity that some individuals can reach. As the justice system seeks to bring closure to this tragic chapter, the memory of Kawsheen Gelzer serves as a stark reminder of the darkness that can lurk within the human psyche, even in the bustling city of New York.
The New York City man’s sentencing serves as a chilling reminder of the capacity for extreme violence that can exist within communities. The details of the case highlight the need for vigilance and the importance of swift and thorough investigations to ensure that justice prevails in the face of such abhorrent crimes. As society grapples with the aftermath of this heinous act, the resilience of the human spirit to seek justice and find solace in the midst of horror shines through. In the wake of such tragedy, the community stands united in condemning the actions of Nicholas McGee and upholding the memory of Kawsheen Gelzer as a symbol of the fight against senseless violence.