Eva LaRue, known for her roles on CSI: Miami and All My Children, endured a 12-year stalking nightmare that haunted her from 2007 to 2019. The actress was relentlessly targeted by an anonymous stalker who sent threatening letters, creating a real-life horror story reminiscent of a movie plot. This distressing period in LaRue’s life is the focal point of the docuseries “My Nightmare Stalker: The Eva LaRue Story,” which premiered on Paramount+ on November 13th. After years of fear and uncertainty, advancements in DNA technology eventually led to the apprehension of her tormentor.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Eva-LaRue-111225-1-6a47507658c74c4c99fba2f0d66d66e9.jpg)
In an interview with CBS Mornings in November 2025, LaRue shared her disbelief at the stark contrast between solving cases on television in a matter of minutes on CSI: Miami and the lengthy process in real life to catch her stalker. The ordeal left a lasting impact on the actress and her daughter, who were both subjected to the stalker’s malicious threats. Despite the challenges she faced during this period, LaRue’s resilience and bravery shine through as she opens up about her experiences to shed light on the harsh realities of stalking.
Eva LaRue’s journey in the entertainment industry started at a young age, appearing in commercials before transitioning into modelling and acting. Her breakthrough came in 1993 when she landed the role of Dr. Maria Santos Grey on All My Children, earning a Daytime Emmy nomination for her performance. LaRue later joined the cast of CSI: Miami in 2005, portraying Natalia Boa Vista for multiple seasons. Her personal life also drew attention, with her marriage to fellow All My Children actor John Callahan and the birth of their daughter Kaya in 2001.
The nightmare began in 2007 when LaRue started receiving disturbing letters signed by the pseudonym “Freddie Krueger,” invoking fear and dread in the actress and her daughter. The stalker’s threats of violence and harm prompted LaRue to take extensive security measures, including relocating multiple times and installing security cameras. The relentless pursuit by the stalker caused immense stress and anxiety for LaRue and her family, disrupting their sense of safety and normalcy.
The identity of the stalker, revealed to be James David Rogers, added another layer of fear to LaRue’s ordeal. Rogers, an Ohio resident and nurse’s assistant, sent numerous threatening letters over the years, escalating the situation with harassing phone calls to Kaya’s school. With the help of DNA evidence collected from the letters, law enforcement was able to trace Rogers and bring him to justice, culminating in his arrest in 2019 and subsequent guilty plea in 2022.
Despite the trauma she endured, Eva LaRue has found solace in returning to her soap opera roots, showcasing her talent and resilience in the face of adversity. Her appearances in The Young and the Restless and General Hospital post-stalking ordeal have not only earned her accolades but also demonstrated her unwavering commitment to her craft. Through her participation in the docuseries detailing her harrowing experience, LaRue aims to raise awareness about stalking and advocate for stronger laws to protect victims.
As she continues to navigate life post-stalking, Eva LaRue’s courage and determination serve as a beacon of hope for those who have faced similar challenges. By sharing her story and using her platform to advocate for change, LaRue exemplifies strength in the face of adversity. Her resilience and unwavering spirit stand as a testament to the power of perseverance and the importance of speaking out against injustice.