Freddie Prinze Jr. Says He Hadn’t Seen Jennifer Love Hewitt Since ’98 Before Recent Reunion: ‘We Run in Different Circles’

Freddie Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt, beloved actors known for their roles in the iconic horror film “I Know What You Did Last Summer,” recently reunited after over two decades since their last encounter in 1998. The duo, who portrayed Julie James and Ray Bronson in the horror franchise, came together once again to film the 2025 reboot of the movie. Despite their on-screen chemistry and shared history, Prinze revealed in a Variety profile that they had not crossed paths for more than 20 years.

In a candid interview, Prinze, now 49 years old, expressed that their reunion for the latest installment of the slasher film was a memorable experience. He shared that despite not having seen Hewitt since wrapping up the second movie in 1998, the connection and care for their characters were still alive. The actors used the opportunity to catch up on each other’s lives, especially their roles as parents. Prinze highlighted that the scene where their characters confront the reality of their relationship was the one he was most proud of, praising the director for bringing depth to their characters.

The revelation about their long-awaited reunion comes after Hewitt disclosed in a Vulture profile that she had not been in touch with another co-star from the original movie, Sarah Michelle Gellar, who also happens to be Prinze’s wife. Addressing the long-standing rumors of a feud between them, Hewitt explained that the narrative was misconstrued, emphasizing that there was no animosity between them. Despite not having seen Gellar since they were teenagers, Hewitt clarified that they were on good terms and dismissed any claims of a rift.

Gellar, known for her role as scream queen Helen Shivers in the first “I Know What You Did Last Summer,” was also absent from the public eye with regards to reuniting with Hewitt and Prinze. At the premiere of the latest installment of the film, both actresses attended separately, and Gellar later addressed speculation about their relationship in a social media post. She clarified that due to the chaotic nature of events like premieres, they were unable to reconnect during the event but expressed her admiration for her co-stars.

As the trio navigates their respective careers and personal lives, fans of the horror film franchise eagerly look forward to witnessing their on-screen chemistry once again. The legacy of “I Know What You Did Last Summer” lives on through the enduring bond between Prinze, Hewitt, and Gellar, showcasing the power of nostalgia and shared experiences in the world of entertainment.