7 Details in “Monster: The Ed Gein Story” That Didn’t Actually Happen in Real Life

Seven Key Elements in ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story’ That Were Fictional

The Ryan Murphy-produced show, ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story,’ delves into the real-life story of notorious murderer Ed Gein. Gein’s heinous crimes have inspired numerous iconic films like Psycho, The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, and The Silence of the Lambs. Initially perceived as a modest small-town farmer, Gein’s facade crumbled in 1957 when he was arrested for the murder of local hardware store owner Bernice Worden and later confessed to the murder of Mary Hogan in 1954. A search of his residence revealed a macabre collection of items fashioned from human remains he procured through grave robbing. Gein admitted to using the remains to craft furniture and clothing. Despite pleading not guilty, he was institutionalized until his death in 1984. Ryan Murphy expressed his fascination with Gein’s story, portraying him as one of the most influential figures of the 20th century.

While ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story’ provides a glimpse into Ed Gein’s life, it also incorporates several fictionalised elements for dramatic effect. Some details were altered to enhance the narrative, here are key points that didn’t align with reality portrayed in the show:

1. Adeline’s Alleged Involvement: The show depicts Adeline Watkins, played by Suzanna Son, as Gein’s accomplice and long-time girlfriend. However, historical records suggest ambiguity regarding the nature of their relationship. Watkins initially claimed a 20-year romance but later retracted her statement to clarify they were merely friends. The depiction of their relationship in the series strays from known facts.

2. Romance with Bernice Worden: The series implies a romantic link between Gein and Bernice Worden, his second victim, suggesting a crime of passion. In reality, there is no evidence supporting any relationship between Gein and Worden. Gein admitted to her murder but maintained a lack of sexual experiences due to his strict religious upbringing by his mother.

3. Unverified Involvement in Deaths: The show fabricates Gein’s role in the deaths of Henry, his brother, and Evelyn, a teenage girl. While the series portrays Gein as responsible for Henry’s death and Evelyn’s kidnapping, factual evidence does not substantiate these claims. Gein’s brother, Henry, reportedly died due to asphyxiation and heart failure during a brush fire incident. Evelyn Hartley’s disappearance remains unsolved, with no direct link to Gein established.

4. Allegations of Necrophilia: Following Gein’s arrest, police found disturbing items in his possession, including a ‘woman suit’ and sex organs made from human remains. While speculation surrounding necrophilia and cannibalism surrounded Gein, there is no concrete evidence to support these claims. Gein, despite his heinous crimes, vehemently denied engaging in such activities.

5. Correspondence with Richard Speck: The show portrays fellow serial killer Richard Speck writing admiring letters to Gein, idolizing him. However, historical accounts suggest no documented correspondence between Gein and Speck. Speck distanced himself from comparisons with other criminals and emphasized his uniqueness in interviews.

6. Misrepresentation of Sexuality: ‘Monster’ explores Gein’s sexuality and gender perceptions, introducing instances where he identifies as ‘gynephilic,’ expressing intense attraction towards femininity. The portrayal of Gein’s interaction with Christine Jorgensen, a transgender activist, introduces complex themes. However, factual evidence regarding Gein’s self-identification remains largely speculative.

7. Inaccuracy regarding Ted Bundy’s Capture: The show suggests Gein assisted in capturing Ted Bundy, another infamous serial killer. While Gein was consulted during the investigation, there is no evidence supporting his direct involvement in Bundy’s capture. Gein’s mental state and lack of cooperation during interviews hindered any significant contributions to solving cases.

While ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story’ provides a captivating portrayal of Gein’s life, viewers should acknowledge the fictional liberties taken to craft a compelling narrative. Despite these deviations, the show prompts conversations about true crime, criminal psychology, and the enduring legacy of notorious figures like Ed Gein.