A Woman Vanished 13 Years Ago. Now, a Coroner Says She Was Killed by Her Partner, Who Died by Suicide in 2022

Woman Killed by Partner 13 Years Ago, Coroner Confirms

A coroner has ruled that a 23-year-old woman who vanished 13 years ago was killed by her partner. Leisl Smith was last seen entering a car with her partner at a railway station in New South Wales, Australia on August 19, 2012. The coroner, Deputy State Coroner Harriet Grahame, determined that Smith was killed by her partner, James Scott Church, before midnight on that fateful day at a remote area in the Upper Hunter region of New South Wales.

Despite extensive search efforts, Smith’s body has never been found. The coroner stated that there is a high likelihood that Smith’s remains are located in the Goulburn River National Park or its vicinity. Church, who was charged with Smith’s murder, died by suicide in 2022 just a day before the verdict was set to be delivered in the murder case.

During the inquest, it was revealed that Church was upset because he felt he could no longer control Smith, whom he believed was pregnant with his child. He was also concerned that his relationship with his girlfriend would be jeopardized if his “ongoing sexual relationship with Leisl” was exposed. Reports indicated that Smith had previously complained about Church’s physical abuse and threats on her life. Church had a history of being abusive towards partners, as noted by officials.

The court heard that Church picked Smith up from the Tuggerah railway station before committing the heinous act. Smith’s father, however, holds on to the belief that his daughter may still be alive. Nevertheless, the coroner concluded that Smith is deceased, acknowledging that not all may accept her findings. Described as a fiercely free-spirited individual, Leisl was remembered as someone who danced to her own rhythm, sought adventure, and embraced joy in life.

In light of this tragic case, the coroner recommended a review of the law concerning the disclosure of verdicts even after a suspect has passed away. Smith’s mother, Sandi Harvey, who has been advocating for legal reforms, expressed disappointment at the lack of closure in the case. She highlighted the need for changes in the justice system to address such circumstances and ensure families get the answers they deserve.

This heartbreaking story serves as a stark reminder of the impact of domestic violence and the devastating consequences it can have on individuals and families. It underscores the importance of raising awareness about the signs of abuse and providing support to those in need. The call for legal reform to address such cases reflects the ongoing efforts to seek justice and closure for victims and their loved ones.

As the investigation into Leisl Smith’s murder comes to a tragic end, the hope is that her story will drive conversations about preventing intimate partner violence and ensuring that those affected by such tragedies receive the justice and support they deserve. The memory of Leisl Smith lives on, a reminder of the need to stand against abuse and uphold the rights and safety of all individuals.

If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic violence or having suicidal thoughts, please seek help from local authorities or contact support services for assistance. Let us work together to create a safer and more supportive environment for all members of our communities.