Jason Biggs Shocked to Learn His First Scene with a Pie Was Not in “American Pie” After Seeing Unearthed Footage

Jason Biggs left shocked after discovering his first on-screen pie scene was not in ‘American Pie’

Jason Biggs, famously known for his breakout role as Jim in ‘American Pie’, was left astonished after discovering that his first acting scene with a pie actually occurred during his time on the soap opera ‘As the World Turns’. The actor, 47, made this surprising revelation during a recent appearance on Live! With Kelly and Mark.

During the show, Biggs discussed his enduring connection with pies, reflecting on his American Pie legacy and how his children, Lazlo (7) and Sid (11), are becoming aware of the film’s notoriety. Biggs shared, “I’m on the cusp of needing to have a conversation because they certainly have heard about it now… They know that American Pie is something, and they’ve asked about it.” The actor highlighted the challenge of explaining the film’s content to his kids after strangers make explicit references to the iconic pie scene.

As more people associate him with American Pie, Biggs recounted a recent incident in New York City where a passerby yelled out, “Hey, it’s the Pie f—–!”. This prompted Biggs to acknowledge that the time to discuss the film with his children was fast approaching. Despite expecting such encounters, the actor was genuinely taken aback to learn that his first involvement in a pie-related scene was not in American Pie, but in his earlier role as Pete Wendall on As the World Turns from 1993 to 1994.

A clip unearthed during the talk show revealed Biggs’ character opting to chase a pie instead of seeking medical treatment for an injury, shedding light on this forgotten moment in his acting career. Amused by the discovery, Biggs expressed, “I have no recollection shooting that. This is the first anyone… That was impressive, whoever found that… 26 years ago, I did American Pie. You would think… wow… that’s crazy.” The actor’s surprise and amusement at this overlooked connection added a new layer to his pie-related experiences on screen.

In an exclusive conversation with PEOPLE at City Harvest Presents The 2025 Gala: Carnaval in New York City, Biggs shared his eagerness to potentially participate in an ‘American Pie 5’ movie if the opportunity arises. Emphasizing his fondness for the franchise and the character of Jim, the actor expressed, “I’ve always said I would 100% be down to work with those people again and to play that character again… it’s one of the best experiences of my life.” Biggs conveyed his pride in the enduring impact of the film after 26 years and the ongoing conversations it sparks among fans.

Jason Biggs’ recent revelation about his first pie scene being on ‘As the World Turns’ adds a delightful twist to his storied association with pies on screen. As fans continue to reminisce about his iconic role in American Pie, the actor’s unexpected journey down memory lane serves as a charming reminder of the varied experiences that contribute to an actor’s career. With his trademark humour and humility, Biggs navigates the complexities of fame and family, embracing both the legacy of his past roles and the potential for exciting new ventures in the future.

The enduring popularity of ‘American Pie’ and Jason Biggs’ candid reflections on his career highlight the lasting impact of iconic films on audiences and actors alike. As fans eagerly await the possibility of an ‘American Pie 5′, Biggs’ willingness to revisit the beloved character of Jim speaks to the special bond he shares with the franchise and the memories it holds for viewers worldwide. In a world filled with reboots and sequels, Biggs’ genuine enthusiasm for reprising his role showcases the enduring charm and nostalgia of the American Pie series, ensuring its place in cinematic history for years to come.