The adaptation of E. Lockhart’s bestselling novel, “We Were Liars,” into an eight-episode psychological drama series on Prime Video has left fans comparing the book to the show. Starring Emily Alyn Lind and Joseph Zada, the series delves into the secrets and tragedies of the Sinclair family on Beechwood Island. The show closely follows the premise of the novel, with the protagonist, Cadence, trying to uncover the truth behind a life-altering event that occurred during her summer on the island. Despite staying faithful to the source material, the show does take some creative liberties to enhance the storytelling.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/we-were-liars-4-050625-52ef7be4da524bdd8f93230c4216b4ea.jpg)
According to writer and executive producer Julie Plec, the series promises to satisfy fans of the book by hitting all the crucial points while expanding on the universe created by Lockhart. One key difference between the book and the show is the timeline of events involving Cadence’s return to Beechwood Island after the traumatic incident. In the book, Cadence spends two years away, whereas in the show, she returns after just one year, setting off a chain of events that lead to the unraveling of family secrets.
The character development in the show offers a deeper insight into the lives of Cadence’s cousins Mirren and Johnny. Mirren’s aspirations to become a professional painter and her struggles with identity are explored more extensively in the series, adding layers to her character. Johnny, who exhibits a troubled and violent side in the show, undergoes significant development compared to his book counterpart, including portraying his bisexuality, a facet not addressed in the novel.
Another notable difference is the portrayal of family dynamics and tragedies, such as Tipper’s death, which occurs in different settings in the book and the show. The change in circumstances surrounding Tipper’s demise adds complexity to the relationships between the Sinclair sisters and highlights themes of privilege, wealth, and rivalry within the family. Additionally, the show introduces subplots like Bess’ infidelity, adding a new dimension to the characters and their interconnected lives.
The character of Ed, who plays a minor role in the book, is given more screen time in the show, showcasing his interactions with the Sinclairs and his yearning for approval from the family patriarch. The inclusion of Gat’s mother in the storyline provides further insights into Gat’s struggles to fit in with the family’s expectations and hierarchy, creating a rich tapestry of relationships and conflicts.
While the book focuses on three Sinclair sisters, the show introduces a fourth sister who passed away in childhood, contributing to the ongoing themes of competition and familial bonds. The revelation of a long-held family secret regarding a fire at Clairmont adds a new layer of intrigue to the show’s narrative, with characters grappling with the implications of their past actions and decisions.
Overall, the adaptation of “We Were Liars” into a compelling TV series offers a fresh perspective on the intricate web of lies and truths that define the Sinclair family. Fans of the book can expect an immersive viewing experience that stays true to the essence of the source material while introducing new elements to captivate audiences.