Staci Keanan and Devon Odessa Say Their Chance to Play Pals on 1987’s “My Two Dads” Was ‘Sabotaged’ by a ‘Big-Time Stage Mom’

Staci Keanan and Devon Odessa Revealed Their Desire to Co-Star on ‘My Two Dads’

Actresses Staci Keanan and Devon Odessa recently shared their disappointment at missing out on the opportunity to portray best friends on the popular TV show ‘My Two Dads’ in the late 1980s. Both Keanan and Odessa, who have been friends for a long time, spoke about this missed chance on a recent episode of their podcast ‘Keanan and Lakin Give You Déjà Vu’.

Keanan, known for her role as Nicole Bradford in NBC’s ‘My Two Dads’, explained that there was a best friend character in the show right from the beginning. The producers of the sitcom were aware of the close friendship between Keanan and Odessa. Odessa, famous for her role as Sharon Cherski in ‘My So-Called Life’, mentioned that she had auditioned for guest spots on the show and that the best friend character was even named ‘Devon’ after her.

The actresses believed Odessa was a strong contender for the role until a significant incident occurred. Odessa’s mother inadvertently disclosed their close relationship to a competitive stage mom, who then wrote an anonymous letter to the show’s creator accusing Odessa of being a negative influence. This false accusation led to Odessa being denied the role ultimately.

The malicious letter included fabricated stories of inappropriate behavior, which deeply affected Odessa. Despite the stage mom later apologizing for her actions, the damage had been done, and Odessa never auditioned for the show again. The actresses expressed their sorrow at the missed opportunity to work together on ‘My Two Dads’ and how it impacted their friendship over the years.

Although Odessa missed out on ‘My Two Dads’, she went on to secure roles in various TV shows like ‘The Facts of Life’, ‘Small Wonder’, and ‘Good Morning, Miss Bliss’. She also appeared in an episode of ‘Step by Step’ alongside Keanan in 1992. The character originally slated for Odessa on ‘My Two Dads’ was eventually filled by Amy Hathaway as ‘Shelby’.

Despite their successful careers apart, Keanan and Odessa lamented the fact that they were not able to portray friends on ‘My Two Dads’ as intended. This missed opportunity left a lingering sense of what could have been for the two actresses. It serves as a reminder of the complexities and challenges often faced in the entertainment industry.

In conclusion, the heartfelt conversation between Staci Keanan and Devon Odessa sheds light on the nuances of Hollywood casting decisions and the lasting impact of missed opportunities. Their story resonates with many aspiring actors and fans, highlighting the importance of genuine friendships and the unpredictable nature of show business dynamics.