Chelsea Perkins, a former Coast Guard veteran and model on OnlyFans, has recently pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for the killing of Matthew Dunmire. The chilling incident took place in March 2021 when Perkins fatally shot Dunmire in the back of the head, alleging that he had previously raped her. The court documents obtained by PEOPLE reveal the disturbing details of how Perkins lured Dunmire into an Airbnb and then to an isolated part of an Ohio national park before carrying out the heinous act.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Cuyahoga-Valley-National-Park-tout-052825-291da50f5b32485985fec12d5407dc66.jpg)
Perkins, now 35 years old, shot Dunmire about four years after accusing him of rape, as reported by various news outlets including Cleveland Plain Dealer, Cleveland 19, and Law & Crime. The tragic event unfolded on March 9, 2021, when hikers stumbled upon Dunmire’s lifeless body in Cuyahoga Valley National Park, leading to a thorough investigation. An autopsy determined that Dunmire’s death was caused by a single gunshot wound to the back of his head, sending shockwaves through the community and law enforcement.
Further examination revealed that shortly before his body was discovered, Dunmire had informed his coworkers about meeting a girl he had connected with online and had plans to see her. Security footage and testimonies indicated that he was last seen getting into a white car belonging to Perkins’ husband, linking Perkins to the scene. The sequence of events escalated when Dunmire and Perkins drove to an Airbnb rented by Perkins, setting the stage for the tragic outcome that followed.
As the investigation intensified, authorities tracked Dunmire’s movements through his phone signal to the Terra Vista Natural Study Area of the park, where the fatal shot was fired. Witnesses later reported hearing a gunshot during the timeframe of Dunmire’s disappearance, adding to the building evidence against Perkins. Descriptions of a woman in black attire wandering aimlessly in the woods aligned with Perkins’ presence, marking a pivotal moment in the case.
A breakthrough in the case occurred on March 30, 2021, when investigators executed a search warrant at Perkins’ residence in Arlington. The discovery of ballistic evidence linking Perkins to the crime scene further solidified the case against her. Subsequently, Perkins admitted to second-degree murder and the use of a firearm during the violent act in a plea agreement with the U.S. Attorney’s Office in the Northern District of Ohio. If the agreement is accepted by the court, Perkins faces a substantial prison sentence of 20 to 25 years.
The chilling narrative of Chelsea Perkins serves as a stark reminder of the complex dynamics surrounding violent crimes and the devastating consequences that follow. The tragic loss of Matthew Dunmire has left a profound impact on his loved ones and the community at large, prompting a reflection on the importance of justice and accountability in such harrowing circumstances. Perkins is scheduled to be sentenced on September 9, 2025, marking a crucial juncture in this disturbing tale of betrayal and tragedy that has gripped the nation.