**Beloved Broadway Stars Celebrate Intimate Wedding on Long Island**
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Marty-Lauter-and-Kyle-Samuels-wedding825-10102026-d2a5116e0fd14e9280e1ae3b842579be.jpg)

On 4 October 2026, actor Marty Lauter, celebrated for their role in *RuPaul’s Drag Race* as Marcia Marcia Marcia, exchanged vows with long-term partner Kyle Samuel during a heartfelt ceremony at Lauter’s family home on Long Island. Their beloved dog, Poppy, played a memorable role as the ring bearer, adding a touch of charm to the special occasion.

The couple’s wedding was an intimate affair, attended by approximately 95 guests, including notable performers from the drag scene such as Luxx Noir London and Jan Sport. Lauter, 29, and Samuel, 30, who first met while performing in *Newsies* in 2017, orchestrated a vintage-inspired wedding that reflected their shared passion for musical theatre and showcased their personal flair.
In an exclusive interview, the newlyweds shared their excitement about the planning process. “We really wanted everything to feel authentic to us, so we did all the planning ourselves,” they enthused. The event was designed to resemble an “elevated backyard wedding,” with a significant focus on personal touches and Broadway-inspired elements.
The couple’s choice to host their wedding at Lauter’s parents’ residence held sentimental value for both. “Marty’s parents have a beautiful, lush backyard,” they explained. “It’s a place that meant so much to them growing up, so we wanted to share it with our chosen family.” The location was also convenient for friends from New York City, making it easy for them to attend.
While the couple hoped for clear skies on their wedding day, they faced a challenge when rain fell throughout the outdoor ceremony. However, guests embraced the unexpected weather. “Everyone said it added a charm and made it more memorable,” the couple reflected.
Fashion played a pivotal role in the celebrations, with Lauter encouraging guests to don outfits inspired by styles from the 1950s to the 1970s. “My personal aesthetic is very granny-chic,” they said, noting the impressive array of well-dressed attendees. Both grooms wore designs from Tanner Fletcher, a brand they admired since attending its presentation in 2023. Samuel wore an ivory suit adorned with crystal embellishments, while Lauter chose a striking black suit with a bow train.
Throughout the celebration, the couple donned three different ensembles each, maintaining a cohesive black-and-ivory theme. Moreover, their wedding bands, crafted by Tiffany & Co., featured a distinctive bow shape, reflecting their fondness for this motif. Lauter’s engagement ring was particularly unique, featuring a pearl in place of a traditional diamond, while Samuel’s ring was designed with smaller diamonds, adding a personal touch.
The couple infused more than just their fashion sense into the wedding; they collaborated with close friends who served as the ceremony’s officiants. They broke the traditional mould by having both sets of their parents accompany them down the aisle, reiterating their belief that weddings can be tailored to suit personal preferences. Poppy’s presence as ring bearer also added a delightful twist, with the couple joking, “She honestly stole the show.”
Music was another essential element of the ceremony, aligning with the couple’s theatre background. The couple chose to walk down the aisle to an orchestral version of “It Only Takes a Moment,” from the classic musical *Hello, Dolly!*, which holds significance due to their shared history in musical performances.
In a refreshing departure from tradition, Lauter and Samuel opted to host a cocktail hour with a buffet-style meal prior to the ceremony. They expressed their desire for their guests to enjoy themselves and be relaxed before the vows. Dinner was catered by Gino’s Pizzeria, Lauter’s childhood favourite, ensuring a nostalgic touch.
The reception featured round tables adorned with floral linens and an array of centrepieces collected from thrift shops, which guests were encouraged to take home as mementoes. Dessert included a Funfetti wedding cake created by a friend, along with Krispy Kreme doughnuts serving as sweet treats.
Despite having many friends who are professional entertainers, the couple chose to let their guests enjoy a night off without elaborate performances. As the evening progressed, Lauter and Samuel shared a romantic first dance to Fleetwood Mac’s “Leather and Lace,” marking a special moment in their celebration.
Reflecting on their journey, Lauter and Samuel acknowledged how their relationship has matured over the years. “Marty brings a lot of silliness into my life, and reminds me not to take things too seriously,” Samuel shared. Lauter appreciated his partner’s steady presence, affirming that Kyle grounds him and is a great support.
Looking forward, the newlyweds have no immediate plans for a traditional honeymoon but instead prefer to enjoy an informal ‘homeymoon’ period. They aim to relax, take day trips, and simply revel in their new marital status. Their aspirations include exploring new adventures and purchasing a home that embodies the charm of their wedding day. “We desperately want to buy property so we can make it as adorable as our wedding was,” they stated.
After nearly a decade together, Lauter and Samuel anticipate that their married life will continue much as it has been. “We’ve been living together for about six years now,” they concluded with a smile, “so hopefully more of the same.”
