Emma Borden, the lesser-known sister of the infamous Lizzie Borden, played a pivotal role in the life of her sibling after the tragic events that rocked their family in the summer of 1892. While Lizzie was thrust into the public eye as the prime suspect in the brutal murders of their father, Andrew Borden, and stepmother, Abby Borden, Emma remained a steadfast supporter during the harrowing trial and throughout the dramatic aftermath, highlighting the complex dynamics of sibling loyalty in the face of societal scrutiny.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/emma-borden-billie-lourd-091626-f4a3547c7aee4ff89a8d9430852fa627.jpg)
Born on 1 March 1851, Emma was nine years Lizzie’s senior, stepping into a maternal role following their mother’s death in 1863. According to the author Cara Robertson, who penned “The Trial of Lizzie Borden,” Emma vowed on her mother’s deathbed to care for her younger sister. However, little is known about Emma’s life prior to the murders. Emma was described as a private individual, preferring to avoid the limelight and even shunning portraits, with only a few photographs capturing her likeness. She remained single throughout her life, living quietly at home while Lizzie’s more flamboyant personality garnered attention.
Their relationship with their father and stepmother was fraught with tension, particularly concerning financial matters. In court, Emma disclosed a dispute regarding property ownership that had arisen five years prior to the murders. A purchase made by Andrew Borden for Abby’s half-sister exacerbated the already strained familial relations. Emma articulated that this incident led Lizzie to abandon any terms of endearment for their stepmother, instead referring to her solely as “Mrs. Borden”. Despite being granted their grandfather’s house following their grievances, Emma noted that the rift with their parents never truly healed.
As the trial unfolded, the sisters’ intertwined lives remained under public scrutiny. Following Lizzie’s arrest, Emma took charge of their financial affairs and generously funded her sister’s legal defence, which featured prominent figures such as former Massachusetts Governor George D. Robinson. Emma consistently visited Lizzie during her incarceration, offering emotional support during a tumultuous time. They even put up a reward for information on their father’s murderer, illustrating their unwillingness to let the horrors of that day define their future.
Notably, Emma’s testimony proved to be instrumental in Lizzie’s eventual acquittal. A critical moment in the trial revolved around Lizzie’s decision to burn a dress shortly after the murders, a move that raised eyebrows among investigators. Emma claimed the idea to dispose of the dress was her own, although she maintained that she did not witness the act. Emma’s explanations regarding the supposed stains on the dress played a significant part in allaying suspicions against Lizzie, contributing to the jury’s verdict.
After Lizzie was acquitted, both sisters relocated to a more affluent neighbourhood in Fall River, purchasing a property named “Maplecroft”. They lived together in the house for twelve years, maintaining a seemingly tranquil existence. However, tensions flared in 1905 when Lizzie began socialising with local theatre actors, including a friend named Nance O’Neil, which reportedly displeased Emma. Following a series of disagreements, Emma chose to leave, and the two sisters never reconciled, living the remainder of their lives separately.
Emma continued to live in Newmarket, New Hampshire, while Lizzie remained at Maplecroft with her dogs, until her untimely death in June 1927. Just nine days after Lizzie’s passing, Emma succumbed to chronic nephritis at the age of 76. Their burial took place alongside their parents in Oak Grove Cemetery, marking the end of a complicated and often tragic family saga.
In a testament to her character, Emma left behind a substantial legacy, comprising over $100,000—equivalent to roughly £1.91 million today—designated for various charitable organisations. Beneficiaries included a local YMCA, the Fall River chapter of the Boy Scouts, and even the Massachusetts Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. Furthermore, she established scholarships bearing her father’s name, reflecting her commitment to her family’s memory.
Emma’s financial bequests reveal a compassionate side, as she allocated funds to relatives, including $10,000 to her cousin Orrin A. Gardner, and $15,000 to another cousin, Preston H. Gardner. Such gestures add depth to the complexity of her character, highlighting her capacity for caring even amidst personal turmoil.
The story of Emma Borden is one that intertwines with the infamous narrative of Lizzie Borden, yet remains overshadowed by the larger public fascination with her sister. Emma’s quiet resilience and substantial contributions to supporting her sister, as well as her posthumous charitable legacy, contribute to a vital aspect of this historical chapter, inviting further exploration into the life of a woman who remained, quite literally, in the shadows.