Two Women Face Charges for 1997 Murder of 81-Year-Old Aunt over $40,000 Inheritance
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Carolyn-Foreman-Dakota-Davis-031325-15bb7d9717c94281a281881cc5aaf8c5.jpg)
Almost three decades after the harrowing murder of an 81-year-old woman in her home in Oklahoma, two of her relatives have been apprehended in connection with the crime. The victim, Gerthie Carolina, was discovered dead on the floor of her house in Sasakwa, Okla., in 1997, with signs of multiple stab wounds and other injuries indicating a brutal attack. Initially ruled as a homicide, the case eventually went cold until November 2023 when investigators from the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation revisited the case.
Recent forensic testing on blood samples found at the crime scene led authorities to the arrests of Carolyn Foreman, 81, and Dakota Davis, 45, who are now facing charges of first-degree murder. Foreman is Carolina’s niece, while Davis is the victim’s great-niece. The motive behind the heinous crime is believed to be rooted in a $40,000 inheritance that Carolina had designated for Foreman, as revealed in documents from April 1997. Authorities allege that the women conspired to eliminate Carolina in order to claim the inheritance for themselves.
The affidavit filed in Seminole County District Court details the events leading up to Carolina’s death, with both Foreman and Davis initially reporting to authorities in 1997 that they had found Carolina deceased upon their arrival to take her to a medical appointment. However, further investigations over the years uncovered incriminating statements allegedly made by Davis to multiple acquaintances, suggesting her involvement in the murder. These testimonies, along with circumstantial evidence, have led to the charges against both women. Despite the gravity of the accusations, it remains unclear whether Foreman and Davis have entered pleas or secured legal representation.
Reports also highlight Foreman’s past entanglement in another murder case related to the shooting death of a teenager in 1999. Although initially charged with first-degree murder, Foreman was later acquitted, while her son was convicted and is currently serving a life sentence for the crime. The tragic events surrounding Carolina’s murder shed light on the complexities within family dynamics and the lengths individuals may go to for financial gain.
In a chilling turn of events, Davis allegedly confessed to her father in 2001 about her role in Carolina’s murder, detailing disturbing actions that implicated Foreman as an accomplice. Witnesses close to Davis further corroborated her statements, painting a grim picture of the events leading up to Carolina’s untimely demise. The unfolding details of the cold case serve as a reminder of the enduring pursuit of justice by law enforcement agencies and the impact of long-standing unresolved crimes on communities.
As the legal proceedings progress, the families involved are left grappling with the aftermath of betrayal and tragedy, exemplifying the lingering consequences of past actions. The intricate web of relationships intertwined with greed and deception offers a sobering reflection on the complexities of human nature and the pursuit of justice years after a crime was committed. The resilience of law enforcement agencies in pursuing justice for victims, even after decades, underscores the importance of thorough investigations in bringing closure to unresolved cases and ensuring accountability for the perpetrators.