Emma Roberts and Evan Peters have rekindled their working relationship as they prepare to star in the upcoming 13th season of the popular series American Horror Story. Their surprise reunion unfolded on 12 May 2026, during the Disney Upfront presentation held at the Javits Center in New York City. This marks a notable return for the former couple, who were engaged from 2014 until their split in March 2019.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Emma-Roberts-Evan-Peters-1-051326-3bb207bccff34646891504b8b7acb95f.jpg)
The pair first collaborated during the filming of the indie comedy Adult World in 2013, before romance blossomed in the summer of 2012. Their engagement was publicly confirmed in January 2014, after Peters proposed during the holidays. Their professional collaboration on American Horror Story has often been highlighted, with Peters previously referencing how working alongside Roberts made their time on set enjoyable and comforting.
The recent announcement also included appearances by several other prominent cast members from the franchise, such as Sarah Paulson, Angela Bassett, Gabourey Sidibe, and Billie Lourd. Excitement surrounded the event as Paul Anthony Kelly, a newcomer to the anthology, also joined the ensemble. With his recent breakout role in FX’s Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette, Kelly noted in a playful comment that “every nightmare needs fresh blood” as he expressed his anticipation for the new season.
Details about season 13 indicate that it will honour the number feared by many, with fan-favourite characters expected to reprise their roles. FX has maintained the suspense by stating that the new season will deliver thrills that loyal viewers have come to expect from the series. An earlier teaser from Ryan Murphy on social media suggested Roberts would return as her fan-favourite character, Madison Montgomery, saying, “Surprise bitch. Bet you thought you’d seen the last of me,” in a cheeky reveal.
The American Horror Story franchise debuted in 2011 and has received critical acclaim throughout its run, securing numerous nominations for prestigious awards, including the Emmy Awards. The series’ ability to reinvent itself with each season has kept audiences engaged and eager for fresh content.
Reflecting on the challenges of their previous relationship, Roberts and Peters faced turbulent moments, including a domestic incident in 2013 that resulted in Roberts’ temporary arrest. Their representatives later described the event as an unfortunate misunderstanding, highlighting their commitment to overcome such hurdles together. Despite these challenges, the couple enjoyed a passionate romance and whimsical experiences at film locations.
After their separation in 2019, Roberts moved on to a relationship with actor Garrett Hedlund, resulting in the birth of their son, Rhodes, in December 2020. However, the couple parted ways in January 2022 and have since focussed on co-parenting their child. Recently, Roberts has become engaged to Cody John, while Peters has also publicly started a new relationship with Natalie Engel, revealed during Milan Fashion Week in 2024.
The significance of Roberts and Peters appearing together again, even if only for professional reasons, has caught the attention of fans and industry insiders alike. Their reunion has raised questions about whether their chemistry on set might spark intriguing storylines in the new season of American Horror Story.
For those eager to catch up on the series, all previous seasons are currently available for streaming on Hulu. As fans await the launch of the new season, the return of Roberts and Peters together on screen has already generated a buzz, igniting discussions about the potential for memorable storytelling in the latest instalment of this iconic anthology series.