Sarah Hyland, known for her role in “Modern Family,” has made a triumphant return to Broadway in the musical adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s “The Great Gatsby.” In an exclusive interview with PEOPLE, she delves into her character, Daisy Buchanan, describing her as ‘deliciously complex’ and expressing her fascination with portraying a character that remains relatable even a century after the novel was written.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/the-great-gatsby-theater-4-022525-725d04167d0740adb3b35ea0fe622482.jpg)

The Broadway musical, featuring a book by Kait Kerrigan and music by Jason Howland and Nathan Tysen, follows the ill-fated romance between Gatsby and Daisy. With Hyland taking on the role of Daisy and Ryan McCartan as Gatsby, the duo brings a fresh perspective to the characters, infusing the production with new energy and dynamics. Despite the challenge of stepping into a show mid-run, Hyland appreciates McCartan’s support and guidance as they navigate their roles together.
Having first graced the Broadway stage in 2006 with “Grey Gardens,” Hyland marks her return after fifteen years with “The Great Gatsby.” She praises McCartan’s vocal prowess and his ability to embody Gatsby with humanity and depth, creating a compelling on-stage chemistry that resonates with the audience. Their mutual dedication to their characters ensures a captivating and immersive theatrical experience for viewers night after night.

The actress acknowledges the influence of her family on her career, particularly her father, a stage actor, who instilled in her the power of silence and emotional expression on stage. Hyland’s parents have been pillars of support throughout her journey, guiding her with their wisdom and experience. As she graces the Broadway stage once again, she carries with her the lessons and inspirations gleaned from her upbringing, infusing her performance with a depth of emotion and authenticity.
Hyland’s portrayal of Daisy showcases her versatility as an actress, delving into the complexities of the character with nuance and sensitivity. The chemistry between Hyland and McCartan elevates the production, drawing the audience into the tumultuous world of Gatsby and Daisy’s romance. With her return to Broadway, Hyland proves her mettle as a seasoned performer, effortlessly transitioning from screen to stage with grace and skill.
As Hyland continues to captivate audiences with her performance in “The Great Gatsby,” her talent and dedication shine through, earning accolades from viewers and critics alike. With a stellar cast and a timeless story, the Broadway musical offers a fresh take on a classic tale of love and loss, inviting audiences to immerse themselves in the glamour and tragedy of the Jazz Age. Sarah Hyland’s triumphant return to Broadway is a testament to her passion for the craft and her enduring talent as a performer.
In conclusion, Sarah Hyland’s portrayal of Daisy Buchanan in “The Great Gatsby” stands out as a remarkable achievement, showcasing her depth as an actress and her ability to breathe life into complex characters. With a stellar cast, evocative music, and a timeless story, the Broadway musical resonates with audiences, offering a powerful and poignant exploration of love, loss, and longing. As Hyland continues to mesmerize theatregoers with her performance, her return to the Broadway stage heralds a new chapter in her illustrious career, cementing her status as a versatile and accomplished artist.
