Christina Applegate has opened up about her tumultuous past relationships in her newly released memoir, *You with the Sad Eyes*. Among the revelations, the actress candidly reflects on her first marriage to actor Johnathon Schaech, revealing that she sensed the union was doomed even before she walked down the aisle.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Christina-Applegate-Johnathon-Schaech-2003-030326-597856302bd84a47a76613209b30dcfb.jpg)
In an honest account of her experiences, the 54-year-old actress recalls the couple’s wedding, which took place in October 2001 after they began dating in 1999. Although their marriage was celebrated as a perfect affair, it ultimately lasted only four years before Schaech filed for divorce, citing irreconcilable differences. The couple reached a legal settlement and finalised their divorce in 2007.
Applegate paints a vivid picture of her wedding day in her memoir, describing it as “a master class in anal perfectionism.” The ceremony, which she described as being “choreographed within an inch of its life,” was marred by what she refers to as a foreboding feeling of doubt. As she approached the altar, her favourite song playing in the background, she was struck by the realisation that she had made a grave mistake. “Oh f—. F—, oh f—,” were her thoughts upon seeing Schaech’s face.
Despite her inner turmoil, Applegate chose not to halt the ceremony, stating, “For a start, I was halfway down the aisle.” In the midst of the pomp and splendour, she was engulfed in a mix of emotions, filled with the desire to avoid self-sabotage. “Don’t be that guy. Don’t be that guy,” she recalled thinking to herself as she prepared to commit her life to someone she already knew wasn’t the right fit.
The memoir also includes some advice for women based on her initial impressions of Schaech. She shares a rather unconventional dating tip: if a man’s shoes are unappealing, it could be a red flag for the relationship’s future. Applegate reflects on her first date with Schaech, during which she fixated entirely on his footwear. They were not cowboy boots, yet they somewhat resembled them; she humourously concluded that they were a poor choice, especially for someone living in Los Angeles.
Despite her reservations about his shoes, Applegate struggled to reconcile her attraction to Schaech’s other qualities. “He’s got his s— together. He’s attractive. He has a career,” she recounted, highlighting the internal conflict that led her to ignore her gut feeling. However, in the end, the pair were distinctly different. She characterises herself as “scrappy,” with a penchant for edgy humour, which she felt was at odds with Schaech’s more polished persona.
Schaech has also commented on his past relationships, including his marriage to country singer Jana Kramer, which ended shortly after their wedding in 2010. He categorised his marriages into two themes—“a little bit country” with Kramer and “a little bit rock and roll” with Applegate—and ultimately suggested that everything had fallen into place for both of them.
Since her divorce from Schaech, Applegate has forged a new life with musician Martyn LeNoble, with whom she shares a daughter, Sadie. In recent years, Schaech has expressed support for Applegate, particularly as she navigates her journey with multiple sclerosis (MS). Following her attendance at the 2023 Emmy Awards, he took to social media to commend her resilience, asserting, “She’s the toughest human being I’ve ever met!”
*You with the Sad Eyes* serves not only as a glimpse into Applegate’s turbulent relationship history but also as an empowering narrative for those grappling with similar feelings. Her story encourages readers to listen to their instincts and highlights the importance of being true to oneself, regardless of societal expectations or pressures.
The memoir is now available for purchase, promising readers an intimate look into the life of one of Hollywood’s beloved stars.