Some Churches Display Anti-ICE Nativity Scenes to Make a Political Statement
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/nativity-ice-sign-121625-1-ea04ed7964f248bba204a58ac7e6f0c8.jpg)
Several churches across the United States are using their Nativity displays to send a powerful political message. St. Susanna Parish in Massachusetts sparked controversy by replacing the statues of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph with a sign reading, “ICE was here.” Urban Village Church in Illinois displayed a sign stating, “Due to ICE activity in our community, the Holy Family is in hiding.” This move aims to draw attention to the impact of federal immigration law enforcement and has garnered both support and scrutiny.
In River Forest, Illinois, Urban Village Church’s outdoor Nativity scene features a sign addressing ICE activity in the community. Similarly, Lake Street Church in Evanston showcased a Nativity display with a baby Jesus depicted with zip-tied hands and Mary wearing a gas mask. The churches aim to prompt discussions on issues such as family separation, detention, and dehumanization faced by migrant families, highlighting the real-world crisis faced by many.
The decision to alter the Nativity displays was driven by a desire to address tangible issues affecting communities, according to Pastor Abby Holcombe of Urban Village Church. She emphasised the importance of welcoming and advocating for immigrants and migrants, aligning with the teachings of Jesus to care for the vulnerable and oppressed. Holcombe highlighted that the church’s display reflects a belief that supporting immigrant neighbours is essential, as it is akin to showing care for God’s own self.
Father Stephen Josoma of St. Susanna Parish in Massachusetts echoed similar sentiments, stating that their Nativity display aimed to shed light on the struggles of refugee families and the importance of addressing their needs. The church’s display, featuring the controversial “ICE was here” sign, intended to raise awareness about the treatment of vulnerable populations and spark conversations about social justice and compassion.
Despite facing criticism and calls for removal from the Archdiocese of Boston, St. Susanna Parish stood firm in their decision to keep the display. Josoma highlighted the significance of engaging in dialogue around pressing social issues, even if it challenges traditional perspectives. The church maintained that the display’s purpose was to evoke empathy and reflection on the plight of marginalized communities amid current political climates.
Supporters of the churches’ displays have praised them for boldly addressing contentious issues and advocating for social justice through symbolic representations in the Nativity scenes. These initiatives have sparked conversations both within and beyond the congregations, encouraging individuals to consider their role in supporting and standing with vulnerable populations. The churches have received varying responses, demonstrating the polarized opinions within society on matters of immigration and human rights.
As the debate continues within these communities, the churches remain resolute in their commitment to advocating for the marginalized and oppressed. The Nativity displays serve as visual reminders of the ongoing challenges faced by immigrant communities and the importance of compassion and solidarity in times of crisis. By using this platform to drive meaningful discussions, the churches hope to inspire positive action and foster greater understanding and empathy across diverse backgrounds and beliefs.