Jonathan Bennett Reviews the Finalists for Hallmark’s “Finding Mr. Christmas”
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/finding-mr-christmas-121525-6-cef08738ebd745f5a562db1ed677cef0.jpg)

Host and co-creator Jonathan Bennett of the popular reality competition series, “Finding Mr. Christmas,” recently shared exclusive insights into the three finalists vying for the coveted role of a Hallmark Leading Man. The season finale, scheduled to air on Monday, December 15, will see either Angel Garet, Craig Geoghan, or Rustin Sailors taking on a role in an upcoming Hallmark Channel Christmas movie. As the show nears its culmination, Bennett reflects on the journey of the contestants and their standout qualities that could potentially make them the next Mr. Christmas.

Over the past eight weeks, Bennett has guided ten aspiring actors through various festive-themed challenges, nurturing their talent alongside guest stars like Hunter King, Sharon Lawrence, and Alison Sweeney. The competition culminated in an emotional finale where the finalists will be tested one last time in an acting challenge alongside co-host Melissa Peterman and Hallmark stars Kristoffer Polaha and Erin Krakow.
Angel Garet, a 39-year-old actor from Charlotte, North Carolina, stood out with his charming and flirtatious demeanour, bringing a unique spark to romantic scenes. Bennett commended Garet for his ability to infuse romance with an exciting and thrilling touch, making him a strong contender for the Hallmark leading man role. Garet’s breakthrough moment came during an emotional scene with Sharon Lawrence, where his grounded emotion shone through, showcasing his versatility as an actor.
Craig Geoghan, a 33-year-old actor from Long Island, New York, impressed Bennett with his comedic timing and willingness to take risks. Bennett lauded Geoghan as the “king of comedy” for his ability to deliver jokes effortlessly and shine in comedic moments. Geoghan’s standout performance in a group scene solidified his position as a strong competitor for the Mr. Christmas title, showcasing his potential to excel in romantic comedy roles.
Rustin Sailors, a 38-year-old multi-talented artist from San Diego, California, caught Bennett’s attention with his natural acting abilities and on-screen presence. With a background in acting, singing, and music, Sailors brought a level of authenticity and groundedness to his performances that set him apart from the competition. Bennett highlighted Sailors’ standout moment during an episode where he portrayed a cowboy, showcasing his potential in roles that require strength and depth.
As the season finale approaches, the tension mounts as audiences eagerly anticipate the announcement of the next Hallmark leading man. The journey of these three talented finalists has been filled with challenges, growth, and camaraderie, culminating in a showcase of their acting prowess in the finale episode. With each contestant bringing a unique set of skills and qualities to the table, the decision on who will be crowned Mr. Christmas remains uncertain.
The season 2 finale of “Finding Mr. Christmas” promises an emotional and riveting conclusion to the competition, offering viewers a glimpse into the world of Hallmark movies and the possibilities that lie ahead for the chosen leading man. As Jonathan Bennett and the contestants gear up for the final showdown, the stage is set for a celebration of talent, dedication, and the magic of Christmas on the small screen. Stay tuned for the grand reveal on Monday, December 15th, as the next Hallmark leading man is unveiled to the world.
