Amy Sedaris Admits She’s ‘Awful’ at Wrapping Gifts and Uses Too Much Packing Tape: ‘I Love How Shiny It Is’ (Exclusive)

Amy Sedaris has candidly revealed her struggles with gift wrapping, admitting that she’s “awful” at the task and tends to use too much tape. The 64-year-old comedian divulged this exclusive insight in an interview with PEOPLE, shedding light on her holiday plans, her passion for crafting handcrafted gifts, and her playful mockery of last-minute shoppers.

Known for her comedic wit and creative flair, Sedaris has been actively sharing gift suggestions on her Instagram throughout the month, offering a diverse range of products from wines to miniature money briefcases. Additionally, she is contributing her own handcrafted items for charity at the Locavore Variety Store in New York City, showcasing items like painted rocks, popsicle stick people, and bookmarks made from uncirculated pennies dated 2025, alongside an unexpected addition of packing tape.

In a self-deprecating humour, Sedaris mentioned the meticulous effort put into crafting the penny bookmarks, highlighting her artistic process with a playful jab at the cost efficiency of the materials used. Despite her creative endeavours, Sedaris humbly acknowledged her limitations in gift wrapping, comically confessing to the excessive use of packing tape due to her fondness for its shiny appearance.

Revisiting her roots in crafting, Sedaris reminisced about her book “Simple Times: Crafting for Poor People,” published in 2010, where she shared her love for simplistic and nostalgic crafts reminiscent of her Girl Scouts days. While she prides herself on creative ideas, she humbly admits her execution may not always be flawless, resulting in charmingly imperfect creations that exude a sense of whimsical charm.

Renowned for her diverse talents, Sedaris recently showcased her artistic flair by decorating her dollhouse for Christmas, adding festive touches such as a miniature tree, wreaths, and gifts. Despite her creative prowess, she acknowledged the chaos in her own apartment due to crafting activities, noting her restrained holiday decorations with a simple yet elegant tree.

Embracing a unique collaboration, Sedaris partnered with Amy’s Kitchen to recreate miniature versions of their frozen dinners for a promotional commercial, showcasing her wit by joking about being the third choice after Amy Schumer and Amy Poehler. Expressing her quirky humour, Sedaris advocated for the frozen dinners as practical gifts for single individuals, highlighting their convenience and versatility for various recipients.

Looking ahead to Christmas celebrations, Sedaris plans to spend the holiday at her brother David’s apartment in New York City, surrounded by friends and family. Reflecting on her completed holiday preparations, including crafting and shopping, she expressed relief at avoiding the last-minute rush and playfully hinted at enjoying the chaotic scenes of procrastinating shoppers.

As Sedaris navigates the holiday season with her trademark humour and creativity, her candid revelations about gift wrapping mishaps and crafting adventures offer a glimpse into the charming eccentricity that has endeared her to fans worldwide. With a distinctive blend of comedy and craftsmanship, Amy Sedaris continues to captivate audiences with her unique perspective on celebrations and gift-giving traditions.