The stars of Hulu’s legal drama, “All’s Fair,” have captivated audiences with their portrayal of cutthroat female divorce attorneys navigating through scandalous and secretive battles. Premiering in November 2025, the series showcases the intricacies of love and war, both on-screen and off. While the characters endure heartbreak and deception on the show, the real-life romances of the cast members tell a much different story. From whirlwind courtship to enduring partnerships, the relationships behind the scenes are as captivating as the drama on the screen.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/alls-fair-real-life-loves-split-110425-8cb09b62aca94b648e3ed351b6ef8483.jpg)
Naomi Watts, known for her role as Liberty Ronson in the series, exchanged vows with actor Billy Crudup in a low-key courthouse ceremony in New York City back in 2023. Their love story began after co-starring in the Netflix series “Gypsy” in 2017, with their relationship becoming public in 2022. Watts has gushed about Crudup’s qualities, describing him as a supportive, intelligent, and humorous partner. Despite sharing two children with her ex-boyfriend Liev Schreiber, Watts and Crudup have found something “quite special” in their bond.
Niecy Nash-Betts, who portrays Emerald Greene in “All’s Fair,” marked her fifth wedding anniversary with her wife, Jessica Betts, in September 2025. The couple, who initially started as friends in 2015, transitioned into a romantic relationship that led to a historic feature on the cover of Essence in 2022. Their love transcends gender boundaries, with Nash-Betts expressing that her connection with Betts is based on the soul rather than any societal norms. Despite having three children from a previous marriage, Nash-Betts found true love in Betts.
Sarah Paulson, embodying the role of Carrington “Carr” Lane, has been in a relationship with actress Holland Taylor since 2015. The pair’s love story evolved over a decade, with Paulson acknowledging the poignancy of being with someone older. Their 30-year age gap has brought a unique perspective on the importance of time and appreciating the small moments in life. Paulson and Taylor’s bond exemplifies a deep understanding and appreciation for each other.
Glenn Close, who portrays attorney and mentor Dina Standish in the series, has chosen to focus on self-contentment following her divorce in 2015. Despite her past marriages to biotech entrepreneur David Shaw, songwriter Cabot Wade, and businessman James Marlas, Close has embraced her independence. The Oscar nominee shared her happiness during an appearance on The Drew Barrymore Show, indicating that she is content with her current state of being.
Teyana Taylor, starring as aspiring lawyer Milan in “All’s Fair,” confirmed her relationship with Aaron Pierre, known for his role in Rebel Ridge, in June 2025. Their connection, portrayed in Taylor’s music video for “Long Time,” is described as healthy, gentle, and warm. Taylor expressed gratitude for having Pierre in her life, emphasizing the safety and joy he brings. Despite having children from previous relationships, the couple’s love shines brightly in their shared journey.
Matthew Noszka, who plays Kardashian’s ex on the show, has been engaged to actress Inanna Sarkis since 2023, as per his Instagram post. Their enduring bond, spanning over seven years, is a testament to love and support in their family. Noszka’s heartfelt message to Sarkis on her birthday highlighted the immense love and appreciation he holds for her. Their shared daughter, born in 2020, adds another layer of joy to their partnership.
“All’s Fair” not only delves deep into the complexities of divorce battles but also showcases the tender and loving relationships off-screen. The real-life partners of the cast members bring a sense of warmth and affection that contrasts the show’s intense drama. As viewers witness the romantic journeys of the stars beyond their characters, it is evident that love truly conquers all, both in fiction and reality.