Stand your ground laws have been a topic of controversy and debate, especially in light of recent high-profile cases like the one depicted in the Netflix documentary, “The Perfect Neighbor.” The film follows the tragic story of Ajike “AJ” Owens, who was fatally shot by her neighbor, Susan Lorincz, in 2023. The incident ultimately led to Lorincz’s conviction for manslaughter in 2024. During the trial, Lorincz’s legal team attempted to argue that her actions were justified under Florida’s stand your ground laws.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/the-perfect-neighbor2-102025-e3009f757b89447a94c6009b3c41fadd.jpg)
So, what exactly are stand your ground laws? These laws essentially allow individuals to use deadly force if they feel threatened, without the obligation to retreat from the situation. In contrast to traditional self-defense laws that require a person to attempt to retreat before resorting to deadly force, stand your ground laws give individuals the right to defend themselves in public spaces, not just within their homes where the “castle doctrine” traditionally applies.
Florida was the pioneer state to pass a modern stand your ground law in 2005. Backed by the National Rifle Association (NRA), the bill received mixed reactions during its passage, with concerns raised about its potential impact on public safety. Nonetheless, the law was signed by then-Governor Jeb Bush, paving the way for other states to follow suit. Over the past two decades, nearly 30 states have enacted their own versions of stand your ground laws, with varying implications and consequences.
Despite proponents’ arguments that stand your ground laws empower individuals to protect themselves, critics highlight the potential negative outcomes associated with these laws. Studies suggest that states with stand your ground laws have seen an increase in gun violence and homicides following their implementation. Moreover, there are concerns about the racial disparities in the application of these laws, with communities of color and Black individuals disproportionately affected.
The case of Susan Lorincz and AJ Owens exemplifies the complex nature of stand your ground laws in practice. Following a series of confrontations between the two families, a tragic altercation led to Owens’ death at the hands of Lorincz. Despite attempts by Lorincz’s legal team to argue her actions as self-defense under Florida’s stand your ground laws, she was ultimately found guilty of manslaughter and sentenced to 25 years in prison.
In response to this devastating loss, Owens’ family and friends have launched the Standing in the Gap Fund, dedicated to supporting families facing similar tragedies and advocating for legislative changes, particularly the repeal of stand your ground laws. The fund aims to provide assistance to those impacted by such incidents and work towards ensuring justice and accountability in cases involving the application of these laws.
The conversation surrounding stand your ground laws continues to evolve as more incidents bring these policies into question. While supporters argue for the individual’s right to self-defense, critics raise concerns about the broader societal implications and the need for reform. As communities grapple with these complex issues, the impact of stand your ground laws on public safety and justice remains a contentious subject that demands careful consideration and discussion.