In a recent legal development, the lawsuit against Nirvana concerning their iconic ‘Nevermind’ album cover has been dismissed once again. The dispute revolves around the album’s cover which features Spencer Elden, who was only a four-month-old baby at the time, swimming naked in a pool. Elden, the plaintiff, alleged that the image on the cover amounted to child pornography and caused him “lifelong damages.” However, U.S. District Judge Fernando Olguin ruled that there was insufficient evidence to classify the image as pornographic.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/nirvana-660-0269944e1daa401199afb0b9b4a8706e.jpg)
Judge Olguin emphasised that apart from Elden being nude on the cover, there was a lack of substantial grounds to consider the photograph as falling within the realm of child pornography. He drew a comparison, describing the picture as akin to a “family photo of a nude child bathing.” Additionally, the judge noted that Elden’s parents were present during the photoshoot, and Elden himself had embraced and financially benefited from his association with the album cover over the years.
The ‘Nevermind’ album cover depicts Elden, now 32 years old, chasing a dollar bill in a pool, a visual that has become iconic in music history. Despite Elden’s claims of significant harm from the ongoing use of the image, the defendants – including Nirvana members Dave Grohl and Krist Novoselic, Kurt Cobain’s widow Courtney Love, and the album’s photographer Kirk Weddle – argue that the image is not of a sexual nature and does not constitute child pornography under the law.
This legal battle dates back to Elden’s initial lawsuit in August 2021, where he alleged child sexual exploitation and sought damages amounting to $150,000 along with legal fees. The lawsuit was previously dismissed by a California judge in January 2022, as Elden failed to respond to the defendants’ motion to dismiss. Subsequently, a U.S. appeals court revived Elden’s suit in December 2023, citing Nirvana’s re-release of ‘Nevermind’ in 2021 as the trigger for the revived legal action.
The recent dismissal of the lawsuit on September 30, 2025, marks a crucial juncture in this protracted legal saga. It has been stipulated that this dismissal represents the final opportunity for the lawsuit alleging child pornography to be rejected. Notably, ‘Nevermind’, released in 1991, propelled Nirvana to global fame with hits like “Smells Like Teen Spirit” and “Come as You Are”, garnering critical acclaim and establishing the band as a pivotal force in the music industry.
As the legal battle surrounding the ‘Nevermind’ album cover reaches its conclusion, the case has raised important questions about artistic expression, consent, and the boundaries of imagery in the public domain. The dismissal of the lawsuit signifies a significant legal precedent in defining the parameters of what constitutes child pornography in the realm of artistic works. The outcome reinforces the importance of context and interpretation in analysing visual content within the framework of the law.