Elisa Donovan Was ‘Making Fun’ of *NSYNC Before They Guest-Starred on “Clueless”. Then She Secretly Dated Joey Fatone

Elisa Donovan, widely known for her role as Amber in the iconic 1995 film “Clueless” and its spin-off TV series, recently shared some surprising revelations about her personal life. In a candid interview, Donovan disclosed that she not only used to mock the popular boy band *NSYNC but also ended up secretly dating one of its members during the peak of the group’s fame.

The revelation came to light during an episode of Pod Meets World when co-host Danielle Fishel, who previously dated *NSYNC’s Lance Bass, probed Donovan about her past with the band. Donovan, now 54, admitted that she had refrained from discussing her relationship with *NSYNC for many years but decided to share the details now.

During the Clueless TV show, *NSYNC guest-starred in an episode towards the end of its third season. Despite Donovan’s initial scepticism and mockery towards the boy band, she was impressed by their professionalism, kindness, and remarkable talent once they arrived on set. Donovan found herself drawn to one particular member, Joey Fatone, and they began a discreet relationship, away from the prying eyes of the public.

Attending *NSYNC concerts with Fatone proved to be an overwhelming experience for Donovan, especially when confronted by the fervent adoration of fans. She recalled moments of being swarmed by crowds and highlighted the intense level of fan devotion the band commanded during their performances.

Notably, Donovan’s involvement with Fatone extended to appearing in the music video for the band’s song “Thinking of You (I Drive Myself Crazy)” released in 1999. In the video, she shared a poignant moment with Fatone where she slaps him after witnessing him kiss another girl. Their on-screen chemistry spilled over into real life, as the pair reenacted the scene at a ’90s Con event in 2023.

Reflecting on her time with *NSYNC and Fatone, Donovan reminisced about their shared experiences, from attending concerts to going out dancing together. She also humorously recalled an incident where the band playfully borrowed a VHS of the movie “Clue” she had rented, adding a touch of lightheartedness to their friendship.

As Donovan sheds light on her past relationship with Fatone and her unexpected journey from an *NSYNC critic to a member’s girlfriend, fans and followers have been intrigued by the actress’s surprising revelation. Her story serves as a reminder of the unpredictability of life and the unexpected connections that can form, even in the most unlikely circumstances.

Through Donovan’s candid storytelling, she invites listeners and fans into a nostalgic trip down memory lane, sharing intimate moments from her past that offer a glimpse into the vibrant entertainment scene of the late ’90s. The enduring charm of *NSYNC’s music coupled with Donovan’s unique perspective adds a layer of intrigue to a chapter in pop culture history that continues to captivate audiences worldwide.