He Comforted Her Family After Her Murder — But a Slip of the Tongue Gave Him Away

Investigation Discovery’s Series Delves into Jessie Blodgett’s Tragic Murder by a Close Friend

An in-depth and chilling delve into the brutal murder of Jessie Blodgett by her close friend is explored in the Investigation Discovery series. The heinous act was committed by Daniel Bartelt, who not only took her life but also deceptively integrated himself into her family’s mourning process immediately after perpetrating the crime. This heart-wrenching incident unfolded in July 2013 when Jessie, a 19-year-old theater student from Wisconsin, was found strangled in her bed.

The news of Jessie’s untimely demise rocked the small town of Hartford and left her circle of drama friends devastated. Among them was Bartelt, who was not only a classmate but also had a past romantic relationship with the victim. The Investigation Discovery series, “A Killer Among Friends,” which premiered recently, sheds light on how Bartelt cunningly pretended to grieve with Jessie’s loved ones, even going as far as reminiscing about her while concealing the fact that he was the one responsible for her tragic end.

Close friends of Jessie recounted the disbelief they experienced upon learning about Bartelt’s involvement in the killing. Despite spending time with Jessie’s family and appearing innocent, Bartelt’s facade was shattered when police linked him to a previous assault just days before the murder. Details emerged that he had attacked a woman in a nearby park, which ultimately led to his conviction for first-degree reckless endangerment. This event served as a crucial turning point in the investigation.

The extent of Bartelt’s deception became apparent when investigators found incriminating evidence linking him to Jessie’s murder, including a cereal box filled with ropes, bloody sanitizing wipes, and tape. DNA evidence later confirmed their connection to the crime scene. Following a meticulous 16-day investigation, Bartelt was arrested and charged with Jessie’s murder, revealing the gruesome details of the crime that included sexual assault and strangulation with makeshift restraints.

In the face of such a profound betrayal, Jessie’s father, Buck Blodgett, expressed profound sorrow and disbelief rather than anger towards the perpetrator. Bartelt was subsequently convicted in August 2014 and handed a life sentence without the possibility of parole, despite his persistent claims of innocence. During his court appearance, he addressed Jessie’s grieving parents, expressing prayers and hope for vindication in the future.

The impact of Jessie Blodgett’s tragic end continues to resonate, with the Investigation Discovery series providing an insightful look into the complexities of the case. As new episodes of “A Killer Among Friends” air, the audience is given a glimpse into the chilling events that unfolded in the aftermath of Jessie’s murder. The show serves as a poignant reminder of the devastating consequences of betrayal and deception within close relationships.

As the investigation unfolds, the series sheds light on the harrowing realities faced by victims of such heinous crimes and the enduring grief experienced by their loved ones. Through meticulous storytelling and insightful analysis, “A Killer Among Friends” offers a compelling narrative that delves into the darkest corners of human nature, showcasing the profound impact of deceit and manipulation on unsuspecting individuals.