Hollywood’s Enduring Love for Iconic Roles: A Look at 22 Stars Who Earned Oscar Nominations for Playing the Same Characters
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/Danielle-Brooks-Oprah-Winfrey-Rita-Moreno-Ariana-Debose-022125-tout-384f7a9212e44d6badbb65e5eb0698fc.jpg)
In the realm of Hollywood, remakes and biopics have always been popular. It’s not surprising that certain iconic roles often make their way back to the Academy Award nominations. However, what sets some actors apart is their ability to breathe new life into these characters, making them their own and catching the eye of the Academy in the process. From the likes of Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoenix portraying the Joker to Oprah Winfrey and Danielle Brooks both earning Oscar nods for the same character, these stars have proved that a great role is always worth revisiting.
Back in 1985, Oprah Winfrey made her acting debut as Sofia in the film adaptation of Alice Walker’s ‘The Color Purple.’ Three decades later, Danielle Brooks took on the same character in the 2023 musical adaptation of the story, also earning a Best Supporting Actress nomination. It’s a testament to the enduring power of Alice Walker’s character and the talent of both actresses in bringing her to life.
Michelle Williams received Oscar recognition for her portrayal of Marilyn Monroe in ‘My Week with Marilyn’ in 2011. In 2022, Ana de Armas took on the role of the iconic actress in the film ‘Blonde,’ garnering herself a Best Actress nod. The legacy of Marilyn Monroe continues to inspire actresses to deliver memorable performances on screen.
Rita Moreno’s historic win as the first Hispanic woman to receive an Oscar for her role as Anita in ‘West Side Story’ in 1961 paved the way for Ariana DeBose to follow in her footsteps. DeBose won the Best Supporting Actress award for her portrayal of Anita in the 2021 adaptation of the classic musical. It’s a testament to the timeless appeal of the character and the enduring impact of the story on audiences.
Marlon Brando’s legendary performance as Vito Corleone in ‘The Godfather’ earned him the Best Actor Oscar in 1972. Robert De Niro later portrayed a young Vito in ‘The Godfather Part II’ and won the Best Supporting Actor award. The torch was passed from one acting icon to another, each leaving their mark on the character in their unique way.
Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoenix both put their stamp on the character of the Joker, with Ledger winning a posthumous Oscar for his performance in ‘The Dark Knight’ in 2008. Phoenix’s portrayal in ‘Joker’ in 2019 earned him the Best Actor award. Their interpretations of the iconic comic book villain showcased the depth and complexity that actors can bring to such roles.
In ‘True Grit,’ both John Wayne and Jeff Bridges portrayed Rooster Cogburn and received Best Actor nominations for their performances. While Wayne took home the Oscar for his portrayal in 1968, Bridges’ take on the character in the 2010 adaptation showcased a new dimension to the beloved character.
Cate Blanchett and Judi Dench both received Oscar nominations for playing Queen Elizabeth I in different films. Blanchett’s performances in ‘Elizabeth’ and its sequel earned her Best Actress nods, while Dench’s role in ‘Shakespeare in Love’ landed her the Best Supporting Actress award. Their portrayals of the iconic queen highlighted the range and versatility of these talented actresses.
Anthony Hopkins and Frank Langella both took on the role of Richard Nixon in ‘Nixon’ and ‘Frost/Nixon’, respectively, earning Best Actor nominations. Although neither actor won the award, their compelling performances as the controversial US president captured the attention of audiences and critics alike.
Kenneth Branagh and Laurence Olivier both received Best Actor nominations for their portrayals of Henry V in different adaptations. Branagh’s take on the character in 1989 showcased his directorial prowess, while Olivier’s performance in 1944 set the standard for Shakespearean interpretations on screen.
While Kate Winslet and Gloria Stuart played different incarnations of Rose in ‘Titanic,’ their performances resonated with audiences and critics. Winslet’s portrayal of the young socialite and Stuart’s portrayal of the elderly Rose both earned them Oscar nominations, showcasing the enduring legacy of James Cameron’s iconic film.
In the biographical drama ‘Iris,’ Kate Winslet and Judi Dench portrayed different stages of the titular character’s life, earning them both Oscar nominations in the same year. Their performances highlighted the complexities and nuances of portraying real-life figures on screen, capturing the hearts of audiences worldwide.
In conclusion, these 22 stars have proven that iconic roles have a timeless appeal that can transcend generations. Whether it’s through historical figures, fictional characters, or real-life personalities, these actors have left an indelible mark on cinema history with their captivating performances. The power of storytelling and character portrayal continues to be a driving force in the world of entertainment, inspiring audiences and fellow actors alike.